The Coli's top 10 Mystery/Suspense Voting Thread. Vol: Edge of My Seat, Breh
- Thread starter FlyRy
- Start date
subs
I'm making an executive decision and closing voting in a couple of hours due to lack of activity
unofficial mod @MartyMcFly approves
so get your votes in if you haven't
unofficial mod @MartyMcFly approves
so get your votes in if you haven't
Without further ado,
The Coli's Top 10 Mystery/Suspense Movies
1. SE7EN
2. VERTIGO
3. REAR WINDOW
4. THE USUAL SUSPECTS
5. THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS
6. PSYCHO
7. CHINATOWN
8. NORTH BY NORTHWEST
9. STRANGERS ON A TRAIN
10. ZODIAC
and for you GIF lovers
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
My boy hitchcock dominated
#MovieClub
#ColiTopTen
@MartyMcFly @HHR @blazn101 @kp404 @Uncle_Ruckus @TheGodling
(just for fun: The Sixth Sense and Mullholland drive were tied for 11th 1 vote behind Zodiac so we almost had a 3 way tie for 10th, and The Third Man was 12th )
Honorable Mentions (not everyone gave one so didn't have much to work with and it ruined this category)
1. Black Swan
2. No Country for Old Men
(Silence of the Lambs was next, but it's on the top 10..everything else was a tie)
-------------------------------------- -----------
3. Diabolique
4. The Sixth Sense
5. M/Fargo/The Shining/Manchurian Candidate/ Primal Fear/3 colors red/Murder on the Orient Express
Gif Lovers:
1.
2.
Discuss Brehs
The Coli's Top 10 Mystery/Suspense Movies
1. SE7EN
2. VERTIGO
3. REAR WINDOW
4. THE USUAL SUSPECTS
5. THE SILENCE OF THE LAMBS
6. PSYCHO
7. CHINATOWN
8. NORTH BY NORTHWEST
9. STRANGERS ON A TRAIN
10. ZODIAC
and for you GIF lovers
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
My boy hitchcock dominated
#MovieClub
#ColiTopTen
@MartyMcFly @HHR @blazn101 @kp404 @Uncle_Ruckus @TheGodling
(just for fun: The Sixth Sense and Mullholland drive were tied for 11th 1 vote behind Zodiac so we almost had a 3 way tie for 10th, and The Third Man was 12th )
Honorable Mentions (not everyone gave one so didn't have much to work with and it ruined this category)
1. Black Swan
2. No Country for Old Men
(Silence of the Lambs was next, but it's on the top 10..everything else was a tie)
-------------------------------------- -----------
3. Diabolique
4. The Sixth Sense
5. M/Fargo/The Shining/Manchurian Candidate/ Primal Fear/3 colors red/Murder on the Orient Express
Gif Lovers:
1.
2.
Discuss Brehs
Last edited:
So basically it's an all Hitchcock list :smugbond:
Yeah 5 of my top 10:smugbond:
TheGodling
Los Ingobernables de Sala de Cine
It's a fairly typical top 10 in the sense it favors Hitchcock way too much (although I'm glad to see Vertigo as his highest ranked film) but I just can't fathom the lack of the Coens and Lynch in the top 10 (more so than the lack of The Third Man).
Breh we were THIS close to a 4 way tie with Zodiac/The Sixth Sense/ Mulholland Drive and The Third man for 10th place
we ended up taking the word "thriller" out of the title halfway through so it leaned more mystery rather than crime drama
duckbutta
eienaar van mans
Also Primer needs to be added to the list...it was the first "go back in time" movie that made me say "now this is the type of shyt that would really happen if someone did this".
Really, it's a shame that this movie doesn't get mentioned hardly at all...I got it in my top 25 ever
Really, it's a shame that this movie doesn't get mentioned hardly at all...I got it in my top 25 ever
Damn great list except Se7en needs to slide a few spots...plus Usual Suspects is a pretty good movie elevated by an amazing twist ending; but it doesn't deserve to be in the same breath as those others...other than that, no problems there
I'd rather have seen Sixth Sense in it's place
and I still prefer Memories of Murder to Zodiac
Last edited:
Uncle_Ruckus
We The North
Se7en making #1 and The Usual Suspects making top 5! 
I need to watch Rear Window now. I've only seen the Shia Lebouf "remake"
I never finished Zodiac.
Didn't know it was that great. Might have to watch it again.
Only upset is North By Northwest being so low and Basic Instinct not making HM.
And you can't be serious putting Black Swan at #1 HMs.
Really?
Salute to @flyry for the work. This might be the second best list we've had so far.