All 3 are nice!
I would go with #2 as the tumbled/ pebbled leather can be worn with jeans, smart casually, business casually and for business (i.e. a nice wool pant, turtleneck and sportcoat).
Small thing I like: The large/ taller tang at the back of the boot too. Let a pant hem catch on it and then you have a brief view of the entire boot (in action) as you walk.
This is exactly what I planned on doing. A very versatile boot for all occasions.
I prefer the color of #3 but I feel the leather is too formal to wear with jeans and also the lining may be too warm for Fall.
The color and look of #2 is good as well, but the 'last' (the mold of the shoe that gives the shoe its shape) is a little wider than I would have liked. #3 has the slim last that I like but the limits I mentioned above.
#1 is good too but that two tone leather just isn't it for me
Meermin is a really good value shoe maker but their styling and options can be very inconsistent. Example: They'll have some Blucher/Derby shoes in black and burgundy but no brown or dark brown
I'm like . I would think you have the basic colors for all of your basic shoes.
If I could get the last and color of #3 with the pebble leather of #2 I'd be gucci.
I feel terrible that I didn't try on boots when I visited their store in NYC . Their shoes ship from Mallorca, Spain and cost $35 to ship with DHL . I would hate to buy the shoes in a size that doesn't fit.
I think I'll go with #2 though. Like you said, much more versatile and the color is a different shade of brown that the dress shoes I just got from them (which by the way just shipped ).
These above (#4) are pretty good but the color is the same as these loafers (below) I'll be getting from them as well.
I tried on the loafers at their store in Soho a few weeks back and man . It was like they were made for my feet. The unlined leather is so form fitting and comfortable. I should have just bought them at the spot because now my size in out of stock online and I'll probably have to wait weeks or even months before their restocked. .
At least by then I should have gotten the two dress shoes and the boots