South Africa's Pistorius Guilty of Manslaughter
Judge Thokozile Masipa has acquitted Oscar Pistorius of murdering his girlfriend but convicted him of culpable homicide, saying he acted negligently when he fired through a toilet door in his apartment.
South Africa: Pistorius Guilty of Culpable Homicide
Pretoria — Paralympian Oscar Pistorius is guilty of culpable homicide, Judge Thokozile Masipa ruled in the High Court in Pretoria on Friday.
"The unanimous decision of this court is the following. On count one murder...the accused is found is not guilty...instead he is found guilty of culpable homicide," she said.
"There is no basis for this court to make the inference that the accused wanted to kill the deceased.
"The conduct of the accused shortly after the incident is inconsistent with someone who had wanted to commit murder."
She initially asked the 27-year-old athlete to stand up before she handed down her verdict.
He stood up with his hands folded in front of him.
He looked straight at Masipa and did not show any emotions when she said he was guilty of culpable homicide.
His family also showed no reaction.
The only sound in the court was that of reporters hastily typing the verdict.
Pistorius was accused of murdering his girlfriend Reeva Steenkamp in his Pretoria townhouse on Valentine's Day last year. He shot her through the locked door of his toilet, apparently thinking she was an intruder about to emerge and attack him. She was hit in the hip, arm, and head.
Masipa said evidential material before the court showed that Pistorius acted negligently when he fired into the toilet door, knowing there was someone behind it.
"It cannot be said that the accused did not entertain a genuine belief that there was an intruder in the toilet who posed a threat to him," she said.
"It could not be said that he foresaw that either the deceased or anyone else for that matter might be killed when he fired the shots at that door."
When Masipa announced her verdict Steenkamp's father Barry leaned forward and laced his fingers on the edge of the public gallery. Her mother June showed no emotion.
Steenkamp's friends started crying.
Her cousin Kim Martins was being consoled by her husband as she sat looking down after Judge Thokozile
Members of the Steenkamp family looked at Pistorius when he stood up.
Steenkamp's friend Gina Myers started crying and was consoled by her mother Desi and sister Kim.
Court was silent as Masipa read out the judgment.
Afterwards Pistorius sat down and stared straight ahead. One of his aunt's, seated in the front row, briefly closed her eyes and her lips moved as if she was praying.
He was also acquitted on charges of illegal possession of ammunition and one of the charges on the illegal discharge of a firearm in a public place.
But he was found guilty on the illegal discharge of a firearm in the restaurant Tashas in Melrose Arch, Johannesburg in January 2013.
The Daily Vox (Johannesburg)
12 September 2014
South Africa: OPTrial - Oscar Walks Away With Lesser Sentence
By Bheki Simelane
Judgement was handed down in the Oscar Pistorius case on Friday, with Judge Thokozile Mapisa finding Pistorius not guilty of murder but culpable homicide. Here's how ordinary South Africans' reacted to the trial.
Eric Langa, 30, unemployed, Chiawelo
Oscar is a white man, he will definitely walk free or will just be slapped with a lesser sentence which will see him walk free in a few years time. This country's laws favors the rich and white. We have seen it happen many times before. Our criminal justice system favors people with money. If, however he does walk free or is found guilty of an offence less than murder, then the rights of women in this country will have been dealt a fierce blow.
Lettie Shabalala, 27, hair stylist, Kwa-Zulu Natal
I have been following the Oscar Pistorius case even though not consistently. I think the killing of any woman by their men is wrong. The killing of women happen everyday in this country, let alone on valentines day. Should the Judge exonerate Oscar on the murder charge that will mean more men will get away with the murder of their partners.
Trust Ndlovu, 30, barista, Berea
Mr Pistorius was not supposed to have killed Reeva. He should have walked away when he saw that the situation was getting out of control but he chose to fight and now loo where his fight has landed him. The man deserves a life sentence for Reeva's murder. When will South African men ever learn to love their women and stop the abuse? The country's criminal justice system has been put in the spotlight and it must prove that it cares about the rights of women.
Melba Ramotse, 28, sales executive, Pretoria
Honestly I am disappointed with reports that the judge could not find Oscar guilty of the murder charge. It's such a sad thing to have happened to anyone, I mean Reeva's senseless murder. Oscar killed a person, the judge can alter the charges to something they call culpable homicide but it will not change the facts. Oscar himself knows this but it will eat him for the rest of his life. He killed Reeva and ought to pay the ultimate price for that. He is guilty of the intentional murder of Reeva. I do not buy his version that he thought he was being attacked.
Tsepo Thelane, 22, unemployed, North West
The killing of a human being by another can never be condoned as a good deed, its wrong. The only time I would regard our justice system as fair is when they lock Oscar up. It would be very sad if our justice system failed to put Oscar behind bars. Guns are kept in safes because they are not play things guns are not toys. They are for protection, for use when one's life is under threat and clearly Oscar's life wasn't under threat. If I was a judge I'd sentence Oscar to life imprisonment.