Flacco aint a 2X SB MVP
The 2025 NFL hall of fame eligibility list has now been released. Who is making it?
- Thread starter Anerdyblackguy
- Start date
Top 10 all time in yards and tds too. Disrespectful ass people.Eli is getting in
2004-2019 NFL Career
Beat the Patriots twice in the SB
Was an Ironman as a QB for #NYG
Had one of theSB plays in history
Lucky_Lefty
Dreams Are Colder Than Death...
Stat padder
Stop. They literally polled voters last year and they didn’t have him in.Eli is getting in
2004-2019 NFL Career
Beat the Patriots twice in the SB
Was an Ironman as a QB for #NYG
Had one of the
threattonature
Veteran
This makes it even worse. The Giants during his whole career weren't looked at as major threats. Even those two Super Bowl years they were a 9 and 10 win team. I don't think Eli was ever considered a surefire top 5 QB in the league. And even during the two super bowl runs it was the defense powering those runs as they never gave up more than 20 points during those two runs. Eli was an overhyped game manager that'll get in off his last name.Eli is getting in
2004-2019 NFL Career
Beat the Patriots twice in the SB
Was an Ironman as a QB for #NYG
Had one of the
Elaborate. I wanna hear your viewpoint on this.
You didn't watch that 2nd title run with these comments. Passed for 5k yards and dragged that team to the playoffs with the worst rushing game in the league and the 27th ranked defense. He had the most passing yards in post season history. Outplayed Rodgers in Lambeau, got the shyt beat out of him in San Francisco and still made the throws to win. Also dropped perhaps the greatest pass in super bowl history to Manningham. You don't think he's a hall of famer? Cool. Game manager? Stop it.
hes not to me either but the SB wins will get him in...mfr led a 9-7 giants team to one of those
42-48 record in nfc east, that’s fb hof material ?
Eli is going to get in whether or not people think he deserves it or not. It's a team game, but two wins in the Super Bowl against the player most consider the GOAT will not be brushed aside. Add to that he's a Manning and played in New York, and he's getting in.
I would say Keuchly, Vinatieri, and Suggs would be the other three I would have go in this year.
I would say Keuchly, Vinatieri, and Suggs would be the other three I would have go in this year.
They had a trash defense most of 2011 until they got hot and no run game. That season was an Eli carry job
Tribal Outkast
Veteran
Luke and Marshawn easily.
Marshawn likely doesn't get in at all.. Fred Taylor is 17th all time in rushing yards and he is the cutoff point.. every running back ahead of him on the list is in the hall of fame..
Corey Dillion, Lesean McCoy and maybe even Stephen Jackson would get in before Marshawn..
Corey Dillion, Lesean McCoy and maybe even Stephen Jackson would get in before Marshawn..
If people are saying Suggs is a lock, then Kuechly should be too. Yes, Suggs had a long career, and a great one at that. And, he did win two Super Bowls. However, Kuechly has four more first-team all-pro selections and one more second-team all-pro selection. He's in a similar situation to Patrick Willis.
If Suggs gets in, then I believe Kuechly should as well.
And, for those saying that Marshawn Lynch should get in, no way.
Killah Ray
Carolina hail to thee....
Honestly at this point how many RBs have a chance to make it in? CMC if he ever gets a ring and ever hits the 2000 mark?