Sonic adventure Vs Mario 64

What was the better 3D Platformer

  • Mario 64

    Votes: 40 74.1%
  • Sonic Adventure

    Votes: 14 25.9%

  • Total voters
    54

Reptile

Reptile For Mortal Kombat 1
Supporter
Joined
Jan 15, 2015
Messages
21,329
Reputation
2,796
Daps
42,448
Reppin
Outworld
Low key Banjo Kazooie and Conker were better games than Mario 64
*ducks tomatoes*

Sonic Adventure was magical imo. I loved it. I loved Mario 64 too though.

77539o.gif
 

March Madness

All Star
Joined
Jan 30, 2015
Messages
846
Reputation
615
Daps
4,898
Diddy Kong Racing better than Mario Kart64 too




Naw let's put it all the way out there




I knew Kart64 was trash when I went over here to Peach's Castle and it wasn't NOTHING over here.

Mario-Kart-6.png


No Warps. No Powerups. NOTHING.
Like damn...Y'all not gone reward me for exploration?
I done ruined my whole race for nothing? Hell kinda game is this.
 

Fatboi1

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 6, 2012
Messages
60,442
Reputation
7,938
Daps
110,673
Diddy Kong Racing better than Mario Kart64 too




Naw let's put it all the way out there




I knew Kart64 was trash when I went over here to Peach's Castle and it wasn't NOTHING over here.

Mario-Kart-6.png


No Warps. No Powerups. NOTHING.
Like damn...Y'all not gone reward me for exploration?
I done ruined my whole race for nothing? Hell kinda game is this.
Facts. Mario Kart 64 was trash.
 

Peter Popoff

AKA Petty Pimpiń..🤑
Joined
Dec 25, 2012
Messages
28,827
Reputation
7,807
Daps
84,517
Reppin
Brooklyn, Texas
What I really fukk with Sonic Adventure.
Me 2 but it's not fuqqing with Mario for a multitude of reasons.

For 1, sonic should've been open world in sonics universe and not earth. Sonic CD was better than sonic adventure imo.
 

Peter Popoff

AKA Petty Pimpiń..🤑
Joined
Dec 25, 2012
Messages
28,827
Reputation
7,807
Daps
84,517
Reppin
Brooklyn, Texas
Diddy Kong Racing better than Mario Kart64 too




Naw let's put it all the way out there




I knew Kart64 was trash when I went over here to Peach's Castle and it wasn't NOTHING over here.

Mario-Kart-6.png


No Warps. No Powerups. NOTHING.
Like damn...Y'all not gone reward me for exploration?
I done ruined my whole race for nothing? Hell kinda game is this.
Waaaaay better. Why'd it have to shyt all over Mario kart like that though. It was essentially Mario kart with upgrades, better levels, hover boats, planes.
 

FunkDoc1112

Heavily Armed
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
19,413
Reputation
5,783
Daps
101,369
Reppin
The 718
Adventure 1 is a childhood defining game for me.
It was magical in ’99.
SA1&2 is the last time we see Sonic as a franchise console-carrying IP.

611809c36d0b0.jpg



Mario 64 wasn’t perfect either, but people will gloss over it's flaws while magnifying Sonic's.
I respect the ambition of the Adventure Team and this is the last time I liked ALL the voice actors.


I haven't liked any of the newer VA's for Sonic lol


Crush40 OST crazy.
Still the best 3D level design in the franchise; only Generations comes close.
Boost Gameplay made Sonic lazy.


Running through Station Square HubWorld and the NPC’s having different dialogue depending on where the story is,
This game, especially for a Sonic game, deserves more respect honestly.
SOmebody on YouTube made a great point: the reason why people aren't as forgiving of Sonic Adventure's flaws is because of all the mediocre-to-bad games that followed; so it's viewed less as a building block/test run of greatness and more an omen of what's to come.

People forget that it was literally the very first major game of the DC/PS2/GC/XBox generation
 

March Madness

All Star
Joined
Jan 30, 2015
Messages
846
Reputation
615
Daps
4,898
Waaaaay better. Why'd it have to shyt all over Mario kart like that though. It was essentially Mario kart with upgrades, better levels, hover boats, planes.


Boss battles and Hubworld too



Kart 64 didn't even respect y'all enough to use 3D Models,
Y'all was driving Badly-Rendered .JPEG Files in Mario Kart...everybody else shyt was 3D.


Sonic wouldn't do y'all like that


1. Diddy KING Racing
2. Star Wars Episode 1 Pod Racer
3. F-Zero X
4. Mario Kart 64
5. Top Gear Overdrive
5. Cruisin World, Cruisin USA


SOmebody on YouTube made a great point: the reason why people aren't as forgiving of Sonic Adventure's flaws is because of all the mediocre-to-bad games that followed; so it's viewed less as a building block/test run of greatness and more an omen of what's to come.

People forget that it was literally the very first major game of the DC/PS2/GC/XBox generation


Makes sense lol


I think another reason was because the Gamecube Ports (SADX, SA2:B) were a lot of people's introduction to Adventure 1&2 too. SA:DX...is not as good as SA1 on Dreamcast, but it is "serviceable". There were more glitches on the Gamecube version honestly. I had a Dreamcast in '99 and everybody pretty much put respect on Adventure 1's name **at the time.



I ain't even bring up the Chao Garden lol
Chao Garden had the streets on lock from '99-'04
 

FunkDoc1112

Heavily Armed
Joined
Sep 14, 2013
Messages
19,413
Reputation
5,783
Daps
101,369
Reppin
The 718
Boss battles and Hubworld too



Kart 64 didn't even respect y'all enough to use 3D Models,
Y'all was driving Badly-Rendered .JPEG Files in Mario Kart...everybody else shyt was 3D.


Sonic wouldn't do y'all like that


1. Diddy KING Racing
2. Star Wars Episode 1 Pod Racer
3. F-Zero X
4. Mario Kart 64
5. Top Gear Overdrive
5. Cruisin World, Cruisin USA





Makes sense lol


I think another reason was because the Gamecube Ports (SADX, SA2:B) were a lot of people's introduction to Adventure 1&2 too. SA:DX...is not as good as SA1 on Dreamcast, but it is "serviceable". There were more glitches on the Gamecube version honestly. I had a Dreamcast in '99 and everybody pretty much put respect on Adventure 1's name **at the time.



I ain't even bring up the Chao Garden lol
Chao Garden had the streets on lock from '99-'04
Yeah DX was based off the build of the original Japanese version that was rushed out so it would be ready for Christmas '98. For the American release a year later they cleaned up a lot of the glitches.
 
Top