It's a new society breh. Tandy is really the first "criminal" to break the "law" of this new society so they are coming up with punishments basically off the whim. I don't believe that they are trying to be as mean as Tandy is on himself. They let him stay in a room after taking him out of the head lock thing. He's being an idiot taking things to the extreme. Also, he talks too much. If he would just shut up, then maybe they would like him, but it's his own mouth and foolish antics (eating the cheese, scaring them with a gun) that is turning them against him. They haven't tortured him since Carol can bring him stuff easily and I'm sure they aren't gonna kill him if he escapes the box. The title of the episode was do the crime, do the time. I think he's done his time, and the next episode will show that. The sneek peak already showed him blackmailing Todd about what he's hiding so I'm sure Tandy (Phil) isn't completely innocent yet. No matter how good he tries to be, you know it's just time before he does something bad again.