The Eddie Guerrero run alone proves that wrong..then u toss in how Bryan carried it and so forth. They left Raw in the dust 90 % of the time after that last Hollywood Rock 03 run.Ever since Smackdown was introduced in 99, the product slowly started dying, mainly because storylines had stretched to accommodate the B show.
The brand extension helped curb this, but now theres too much talent which means more salaries to be paid.
The E needs to go back RAW and RAW only. Obviously won't happen, but it would improve things.