Are you done with John Jerry too? Because he was easily the worst lineman yesterday, and I'm more upset at him still being in the starting line this season than anything else.
SBE X ODB:Thats Tha Gang Biitch --The Official 2018 New York Giants OffSeason Thread
- Thread starter Ku$h Parker
- Start date
the next guy
Superstar
eli is old, they should be been looking for his replaced a while ago. The o - line needs whatever type of glue or stickers at this point otherwise Eli might not play 16 games.
Davis-Webb
The War Report
NewNewYork
You ain't helping your point, manito. He's just 23 and entering his 3rd season...plus he wasn't horrible on Sun.They're not the same. John Jerry is 31 and was a 3rd rounder. Eric Flowers is 23 and was the 9th pick of the draft.
Jerry is 31 and hasn't really been starter level since he left the Dolphins.
Ironman
#Knickstape
I actually agree we have the most aggressive news in this country regardless of sport it's timeMedia needs to start goin at MacadooOdell , Spags and the defense have carried him
Maybe him being full time OC again may help him relax and expand but gotdamn 
And jackass management NEEDS to say fukk Flowers and go all in to improving the O-line. We really need to start looking at a qb too
the next guy
Superstar
Yup. And he's mediocre too.
Is there anyone left on waivers? Who can we trade?
Last edited:
The War Report
NewNewYork
the next guy
Superstar
Spags should have been HC @JerseyBoy23 remember we were talking about this.Media needs to start goin at Macadoo
I always argued there wasn't much they could have really done with the OL given the talent pool available this past offseason, but the Vikings somehow found five new and so far successful starters, so @ me trying to give this team a pass.
He's got it working now, now that the D is loaded with talent, but that dude is lucky the Giants even kept him as DC after the 2015 defensive disaster and instead put it all on the players. I never fukked with Fewell too heavily, but he's stuck as a position coach for life (if he even gets to keep that job) after failing less and less epically than Spags spent most of a decade doing. White privilege wouldn't even have begun to cover him being promoted to HC when Coughlin was let go with his resume at that time.
@ me trying to give this team a pass.Based on how awful he did in St Louis and how he was coming off multiple historically terrible defenses?
He's got it working now, now that the D is loaded with talent, but that dude is lucky the Giants even kept him as DC after the 2015 defensive disaster and instead put it all on the players. I never fukked with Fewell too heavily, but he's stuck as a position coach for life (if he even gets to keep that job) after failing less and less epically than Spags spent most of a decade doing. White privilege wouldn't even have begun to cover him being promoted to HC when Coughlin was let go with his resume at that time.
JerseyBoy23
Veteran
Yup. I think they'd be in a better place with Spags at the helm over McAdoo. I know Odell was out but I feel like there was no pep in their step on Sunday, I feel like the offense gave up.
godkiller
"We are the Fury"
He wqs drafted in the 3rd round, played consistently worse than Brad Kaaya (who raced better competition and was still cut by the Lions, and cannot beat out Geno Smith.
On the Giants' roster, the most talented,youngest and best fit for McAdoo's quick hittng WCO is Geno Smith.
Looking back on it, Webb was outplayed by about every rookie QB I watched and many of those QBs weren't even good. 3rd round QBs, unless they were passed over for attitude, race, height, size or something like it never work out.
Broad Street Bully
Sick & Tide Sixers/Phillies/Cowboys fan smh
godkiller
"We are the Fury"
McAdoo is a fine HC. Eli just declining and cant run a WCO offense now more than ever.
Eli is sees shadows in the pocket like Blaine Gabbert, is ponderously slow (worse than about every QB in the league), is inaccurate (whether he has time or not), turnover prone.
And all of Eli's faults are magnified without OBJ turning Eli from a bottom 5 QB to an average one.
One good game against a weak GB defense with OBJ doesnt mean anything. Any vet backup can look good against a weak defense with e best receiver in the league.
McAdoo is not to blame because Eli cant throw accurate 5 yard passes in 3rd and the 3. Trevor Siemian does it all say.