Say man.... Eli Manning ain't elite.

[TheNig]

He just had a good ass season last season. He has two Super Bowls under his belt but I was just looking at his numbers for this yr and that shyt is middle of the road like shyt. He's not bad. But he's not that good. I need Giants fans to explain this. Only becuz I actually like dude but he's not nearly as good as I thought he was.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Oh hey it's this thread again

 

[dabigdogg]

Another silly ass thread from a fakkit ass poster

 

[Nintendough]

Eli wins chamionships, how is that not elite?

 

[TheNig]

Honestly... I've never seen this thread made before.

 

[TheNig]

Eli wins chamionships, how is that not elite?

His numbers say otherwise.

 

[Dat916nigga]

this topic has been done to death

 

[Stone]

He's in that next tier with Brees, Ben, Romo and Ryan. Brady, Rodgers and Peyton are the elite.

 

[MAKAVELI25]

It's debatable

Honestly, Eli is in the same class with Ben in that without the championships there is no real argument for him being elite. They are both borderline imo. Someone like Manning or Rodgers has a strong argument even without the championship but it's cemented WITH the championship. Thats the difference between borderline and actually elite from my perspective

 

[Kenny West]

He's got a powerful clutch gene, but he is mistake prone. He's good for one interception per game

 

[MAKAVELI25]

He's in that next tier with Brees, Ben, Romo and Ryan. Brady, Rodgers and Peyton are the elite.

No, Romo and Ryan are not in the same class as Eli, Ben, and Drew. They are all arguably elite, anyone who would argue that Romo or Ryan is elite is an idiot

 

[Domingo Halliburton]

It's debatable

Honestly, Eli is in the same class with Ben in that without the championships there is no real argument for him being elite. They are both borderline imo. Someone like Manning or Rodgers has a strong argument even without the championship but it's cemented WITH the chmampionship. Thats the difference between borderline and actually elite from my perspective

I'm going to do the-coli ad hominem and say STFU because you're an eagles fan

 

[dabigdogg]

Agreed. fukk Romo and Caccy Ice

 

[Stone]

No, Romo and Ryan are not in the same class as Eli, Ben, and Drew. They are all arguably elite, anyone who would argue that Romo or Ryan is elite is an idiot

Seasons that Ryan and Romo are having right now >>>>>> any season that Eli and Ben have ever had.

Seriously, who is playing better quarterback than Matt Ryan is right now other than the top 3?
If we at least get to the SB this year there won't be any denying it.

Romo is surrounded by so much fukkery on a yearly basis that it takes away from the fact that he's REALLY good.

 

[MAKAVELI25]

Seasons that Ryan and Romo are having right now >>>>>> any season that Eli and Ben have ever had.

Seriously, who is playing better quarterback than Matt Ryan is right now other than the top 3 and RG3?

Ryan is NOT elite. It is not even debatable. No Quarterback who hasn't gotten past the first round of the playoffs should be even arguable as elite, Ryan hasn't even done enough to prove he's as good as a Roethlisberger or Eli, yet you're trying to say he's in that Brady/Rodgers/Manning class. I'm not even going to put down an argument as to why Romo isn't elite