Questlove defends Vol 1, Jay-Z responds

Easy-E

I 💗My Tribal Chief
Supporter
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
53,333
Reputation
9,375
Daps
158,897
Reppin
NO/VA/Nashville
I Know What Girls Like was a ahead of it's time? Time for what, to throw it in the recycle bin where it belongs? :mjlol:

A Million Questions, Where I'm From, Friend or Foe '98 & Imaginary Players make it worth a listen

Yep, three of these are Top 50 Jiggaman songs.
 

Easy-E

I 💗My Tribal Chief
Supporter
Joined
Jun 8, 2012
Messages
53,333
Reputation
9,375
Daps
158,897
Reppin
NO/VA/Nashville
Impossible to follow up Reasonable Doubt. That album was held in such high esteem that Jay’s next album was highly anticipated. Cats were waiting to cop that next album day one when they knew the release date. You couldn’t tell folks shyt! BIG had got killed in March and so real Hip-Hop heads needed Jay to carry that torch and really waited for that Vol. 1 to hit the streets. Now on to why in real time the album was a letdown (Albeit some very classic cuts on the album).

This sounds like revisionist history.

I'd like to see proof of that. Because you're basically making the Illmatic --> It Was Written argument and that it one of the most celebrated album from it's actual release date. Not the RD shyt where ppl call it classic years later.

There's a reason Jay did a 360 from RD to Vol 1 back to Street's Is Watching

The shyt almost derail his career and he had to hop on trends until atleast Dynasty (where the modern Rocafella sound was born, IMO).
 

MikeStamina

All Star
Joined
Jul 3, 2018
Messages
3,688
Reputation
-458
Daps
9,565
Didn't I JUST speak on how jay move on the Magic thread?

I been around a minute n know wtf I be talking about when I speak.

But you muhfukkas love arguing

@JustCKing


Nas will never ever insert himself in these types of discussions.
 

Controversy

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2015
Messages
12,842
Reputation
-393
Daps
34,186
Reppin
Philly
Ppl in Philly rocked with Vol. I heavy...Philly was all in on Jay before he became a success with Vol. II

The 3 most played tracks in Philly were Face-off, Where I'm From & Who U Wit

Who U Wit got heavy radio play
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,202
Reputation
3,789
Daps
47,629
Reppin
NULL
Didn't I JUST speak on how jay move on the Magic thread?

I been around a minute n know wtf I be talking about when I speak.

But you muhfukkas love arguing

@JustCKing


Nas will never ever insert himself in these types of discussions.

What does this have to do with responding to publications with obvious bias though?

?uestlove is not some random nobody. Jay actually respects his opinion, so it's not a surprise that he would respond.
 

Threnody

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
7,044
Reputation
911
Daps
25,335
Vol.1 is one or two missteps from being classic but "I know what girls like" is hot garbage

I still can't figure out who that song was even for? bytches didn't like it, heads didn't like it
most jay stans don't fukk with it.....who was suppose to rock with that shyt? song shouldn't even exist
the beat isn't bad nor is the rapping it just makes no sense as a song if quest thinks its was something more
to that shyt he needs to break it down cause I really don't see it

After reading this thread
nikkas who don't like 'Lucky Me" got horrible taste that song is a work of art and the beat is :ohlawd:

"Lucky Me" is also the only song Jay said he made as "SC"
his Jay-Z persona is nowhere to be found on the track its one of a kind and fukking classic

oh and anybody who thinks vol.3 is more lyrical than vol.1 is smoking crack that opinion is retarded
Jay even admitted he phoned that album in

its a good seven to ten songs on vol.1 thats the best shyt Jay-Z ever put out :wow:

replace sunshine and I know what girls like with these two and its classic!



 
Joined
Feb 14, 2014
Messages
250,288
Reputation
48,461
Daps
544,143
It fits the sentimental lyrics of the track perfectly as well as the singing and Jay’s backing vocals. :dwillhuh:

That beat is hot trash. shyt is garbage :mjlol:

Beat sound like corny ass elevator music :russ:


and that song is a perfect example of how Jay usually always sound so empty on his introspective and retrospective songs. Introspective/retrospective songs are not Jay's strong points at all
 
Top