Fields got a huge hitch in his throwing motion, Trey gets knocked for having a windup but there was a breakdown of all the first round QBs last year and Fields literally take twice as long as the rest of em from start of throwing motion to finish. Feel like that was the deal breaker in an offense that prize getting the ball out quick. Fields a better fit for a vertical offense
Also take a look at Fields numbers last year. I understand the team and coach was ass but his numbers was trash. Completed 59% his passes with a 6.9 YPA, 7 TD vs 10 INT, QB rating of 72. Trey completed 58%, 8.5 YPA, 5 TDs vs 2 INT, passer rating of 97 but you listen to the internet, Trey a bust and Fields a first ballot hall of famer