Poll: 2 years of CM Punk in AEW. Rate it on a scale of 1-10.

[Ripp]

I gave him a 10... I dont fukk with dude at all. You can probably see me talking shyt about him in past threads and that nasty ass elbow drop

But I gave him a 10 for beating Kenny Omega and the yung yang twins asses. And calling out that butterfly jeaned p*ssy... good work Phil

 

[NkrumahWasRight Is Wrong]

7

Great debut, good matches and promos, strong quality on collision, intriguing drama

Downside was absence, turmoil and diminished working ability. Still can work but not at the level he did

Seems like he has some creative control over collision and I think its mostly been a good program

Theres money in an elite feud but there always will be. I dont think they need to rush into doing that if it was to ever occur. That's an easy build

 

[Dipsey Doo]

I gave it a 5.

The Rampage debut was a great wrestling moment. I've never been a CM Punk fan like that, but it was an all time great moment.

His feud with MJF was pretty good.

That's pretty much all the good I can think of.

His in-ring performance has been up and down, he's too old to be doing the flippy flop 100 miles an hour AEW style stuff. I cringed when he botched the Buckshot Lariat.

The All Out scrum was hilarious, but it hurt Tony Khan's business all things considered. The period from All Out until the Elite comeback was some of the worst episodes of AEW television.

The needless drama and politicking are points deducted against Punk.

He's spent more time on the shelf then on TV

The return on the investment hasn't been there.

I'll be honest, he should have went back to WWE. HHH has the special sauce right now and has a knack for making his top guys look like big stars. WWE has a lot of guys Punk can work with and headline PLEs with.

 

[R=G]

 

[Brad Piff]

After today, would you change your score higher or lower, brehs?

 

[L68]

6 .. a handful of really good promos and matches. Nothing really great

 

[MushroomX]

After today, would you change your score higher or lower, brehs?

6, he kept his promise.

 

[julesocean]

I'd give it a 7.

Starpower: 9
In-ring: 6
Entertaining over-all: 8
Durability: 3

Even with all the drama and missed time, still very much worth it for AEW.

 

[DoubleJ13]

I would go 5, just completely middle of the road

Ah shucks, happy to be here Punk doesn't do anything for me. The MJeff stuff was great but everything else has felt like quickly get through it & on to the next thing without really getting into anything stuff.

 

[KateFabersBoyfriend]

After today, would you change your score higher or lower, brehs?

I'd raise it to a 6. For every other AEW pillar he gets into an altercation with id raise it another point.

 

[Silkk]

After today, would you change your score higher or lower, brehs?

Higher

JUST GET THE shyt ON TV


I’ve never seen a booker go so hard out of their way to not capitalize on the buzz he’s given.

 

[prophecypro]

Still puts on good matches after watching All In

Drama may come but theres something to be said about 80% of the others

 

[R=G]

I would go 5, just completely middle of the road

Ah shucks, happy to be here Punk doesn't do anything for me. The MJeff stuff was great but everything else has felt like quickly get through it & on to the next thing without really getting into anything stuff.

Yeah 5...alot of momentum but all these tiffs and issues should be beneath him.

 

[L68]

6 .. a handful of really good promos and matches. Nothing really great

I lower it one point to 5 now that hes fired.. Getting into fights with midgets smh

 

[StackBundles]

1 that nikka garbage. Idk what the hype is about that cac