Peter Rosenberg hating on these R&B battles is proof that you cant trust rap opinions from this dude

tremonthustler1

aka bx_representer
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
82,635
Reputation
8,825
Daps
204,208
Reppin
My Pops Forever RIP
I can't entirely knock Rosenberg line of thinking on the R&B battles, although with his platform he shouldn't have said anything. Then again, so what. Man is entitled to his opinion. I never listed to R&B from the 90's, 2000 era. I couldn't name you one Brandy song, or Monica song. Couldn't name you not one Babyface song. I never listened to that stuff coming up. I barely remember Al B Sure and Bobby Brown. Plenty of dudes like that too. Whether they was into C-Bo or Murs.
Maybe it's because I had sisters who were into their R&B way more than I was, you have to try to avoid listening to R&B to not know of the big records that came out. I can see if you didn't know a deep album cut or whatever, but it's hard to not know those songs, at least the major songs, unless you were a total snob or didn't really grow up in that culture.

Rosenberg is the guy who only watched Rap City, the guy who when Ralph McDaniels decided to go old school and show throwback R&B /soul /reggae on Video Music Box, decided to take the day off, the guy who if there wasn't a rapper on Soul Train he didn't know, didn't even leave it on as background noise.
 

BK The Great

Veteran
Joined
Nov 21, 2015
Messages
56,248
Reputation
5,731
Daps
138,465
Reppin
BK NY
I know my fair share of R&B, from Usher, Mary J. Blige, Alicia Keys, Mariah Carey, some Brandy songs, New Edition, Bobby Brown, Whitney Houston, MJ, Chris Brown, Ryan Leslie, Neyo, 112, Aaliyah, Janet Jackson, some of Jon B and many more. Still trying to grow my playlist from songs i remember from the past.
 

George's Dilemma

Banned
Supporter
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
27,794
Reputation
7,474
Daps
136,049
Maybe it's because I had sisters who were into their R&B way more than I was, you have to try to avoid listening to R&B to not know of the big records that came out. I can see if you didn't know a deep album cut or whatever, but it's hard to not know those songs, at least the major songs, unless you were a total snob or didn't really grow up in that culture.

Rosenberg is the guy who only watched Rap City, the guy who when Ralph McDaniels decided to go old school and show throwback R&B /soul /reggae on Video Music Box, decided to take the day off, the guy who if there wasn't a rapper on Soul Train he didn't know, didn't even leave it on as background noise.


Agreed. I didn't have sisters around during that time frame as they're older and I was left to myself. During my teenage years, around other dudes we never listened to Babyface. I'd watch videos of Jodeci, Blackstreet, R Kelly, etc, but buying an album of theirs? Naw, just wan't happening.

Rosenberg said he was a backpacker, and they definitely weren't listening to anything but Hip Hop, and some of that crowd was real snobbish too with it. The Def Jux stans were insufferable.
 

DaMos Supreme

All Star
Joined
May 10, 2012
Messages
959
Reputation
280
Daps
2,878
Reppin
NULL
Yeah, yeah, I understand the whole we are not monolithic thing but some of you coming across defensive .

I mean some you never heard gospel, blues-juke joint records, funk, soul-Motown, semi-disco, R&B records from your grandparents, uncs, aunts, parents and etc at cookouts, house parties/card games, family reunions, Saturday-Sunday Morning cleaning :mjtf:.

I can honestly say I never came across any black person with disdain or dislike R&B in my life.
 
Last edited:

Chip Skylark

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jan 2, 2014
Messages
23,233
Reputation
3,745
Daps
64,065
Yeah, yeah, I understand the whole we are not monolithic thing but some of you coming across defensive .

I mean some you never heard gospel, blues-juke joint records, funk, soul-Motown, semi-disco, R&B records from your grandparents, uncs, aunts, parents and etc at cookouts, house parties/card games, family reunions, Saturday-Sunday Morning cleaning :mjtf:.

I can honestly say I never came across and black person with disdain or dislike R&B in my life.



all of this! hip hop, soul, r&b, gospel literally go hand in hand with each other. it’s our culture
 

Homeboy Runny-Ray

From Around The Way
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
20,724
Reputation
-950
Daps
20,077
Reppin
Classic Niccas
Yeah, yeah, I understand the whole we are not monolithic thing but some of you coming across defensive .

I mean some you never heard gospel, blues-juke joint records, funk, soul-Motown, semi-disco, R&B records from your grandparents, uncs, aunts, parents and etc at cookouts, house parties/card games, family reunions, Saturday-Sunday Morning cleaning :mjtf:.

I can honestly say I never came across any black person with disdain or dislike R&B in my life.


they exist.

theyre weirdos.

usually, theyre the types of black people who swear by eminem.
 

philmonroe

Superstar
Joined
Jun 19, 2012
Messages
28,909
Reputation
730
Daps
37,464
Reppin
The 215
I can't entirely knock Rosenberg line of thinking on the R&B battles, although with his platform he shouldn't have said anything. Then again, so what. Man is entitled to his opinion. I never listed to R&B from the 90's, 2000 era. I couldn't name you one Brandy song, or Monica song. Couldn't name you not one Babyface song. I never listened to that stuff coming up. I barely remember Al B Sure and Bobby Brown. Plenty of dudes like that too. Whether they was into C-Bo or Murs.
I ain't going to lie ime the dudes like you were all dusty scammer dudes growing up. Nothing wrong with it just that who was the I don't listen to rnb crew and wanted to yack all day about pure hip hop where I was at
 
Top