You mention Orton but he showed up every week. Sure he phoned it in but he was still on TV on a regular basis. The only reason Orton was gone for so long recently was because of his injury and TrashGate.
If he's once in a lifetime how about he uses more than 3 moves?
I'm not asking for him to be like early 2000s Brock but put some effort into your matches. After all he's part of the entertainment industry. If Brock wanted to he could do a 20 minute PPV match and no one could tell him no. He just chooses not to. Even old ass Undertaker put in some work for his yearly Wrestlemania matches.