I was about to tag u when I saw his answer.
The unwarranted confidence in Geno is unique will give you that.
I was about to tag u when I saw his answer.
every QB excels when they have a pocket around them...the NFL rules are designed for passing
What does this have to do with your backpeddling thing you FAILED to tie to Winters play?
Geno is not Derek Carr who consistently does so for nothing.
**from YOUR friends at football outsiders**
You don't watch film
so I'm going to put words in your mouth because my points were trash
I'm clearly saying that the factors that I have a long said affected him ( horrible receiving core, Bad play guard ) was mostly responsible for his poor play. Once those things changed, his play improved! That is the reason why I believe he will play better. If he played poorly with the changes I asked for then I would agree with you. That is where my point comes from. And this is where you you and I disconnect. You don't acknowledge Brian winters. You don't acknowledge Steven Hill, Clyde Gates, David Nelson, Greg Salas .I do.Ha. You're trying to spin Geno's first two seasons into something they weren't. He's been bad, I don't get the effort into defending it.
Stats don't lie.
I'm clearly saying that the factors that I have a long said affected him ( horrible receiving core, Bad play guard ) was mostly responsible for his poor play. Once those things changed, his play improved! That is the reason why I believe he will play better. If he played poorly with the changes I asked for then I would agree with you. That is where my point comes from. And this is where you you and I disconnect. You don't acknowledge Brian winters. You don't acknowledge Steven Hill, Clyde Gates, David Nelson, Greg Salas .I do.
I said nothing about "seasons." You are now moving it to that argument like the goalpost mover you are.
Watch film.
I'm sure you won't respond to me and not to diss Trip at all cause I don't know his football acumen but I can get on your level and I always win our debates which you usually resort to other tactics outside of football to try to win. All in all you cool people's in my book and we just debating no need to take serious but you've been wrong about a lot.
Let's start with your fantasy that Idzik and Rex was good with each other cause you seen them acting buddy buddy not realizing that's just business. Let's get into Geno and why he really should of never started his rookie year in first place. Rex wanted Sanchez to start and Idzik wanted Geno so obvious with that botched competition. What rookie Qb comes straight into gate receiving first team reps without him earning it ? That's entitling a player and let's not forget how raw Geno was. Geno had the most horrendous footwork ever dude couldn't even do a 3 step drop without it looking bad. Then on top of that when a player usually gets hurt during training camp or pre-season they rest him but not case with Geno they had dude hobbling on a fukked up ankle cause Idzik wanted Geno so bad. By no means did Sanchez really outshines Geno by miles but he had better training camp and pre-season games dude was suppose to be starter not Geno but you know how that story goes.
Rebel you're coming from a biased opinion because you found a player you like and ignore a lot of things to push your agenda. You know how I know you're biased look how much praise you give Geno but never gave Sanchez and Geno hasn't done shyt in this league. Remember those nikka with a telestrater Geno threads and etc. Your opinion is madly biased it's not funny. You blame everything around Geno instead of giving him blame he deserves. Then you hand pick things that will support your argument but ignore one's that won't. This nfl which has a salary cap so not every player is going to be great on offense but a good qb still steps up to occasion. We have enough work to see Geno doesn't have a clue out their at all and mentally doesnt have it. People ignore mental toughness a QB suppose to have where he always keep that mentality even when shyt is fukking up bad he still hangs in there and gets the job done. Dude just doesn't have it mentally right now and I say right now cause it could chane. But how many times have seen Geno Start games horrendous but pull through? Not many and he's started off bad plenty of games. Only way I see Geno succeeding is if they dumb that offense down for him which looks like the plan with Chan Gailey because that west coast offense is not for him. Dude just doesn't have abilities to read defenses etc. And you keep showing that one play where he had to run and throw ball away but that's actually on Geno because if he read the blitz right he should of change play or hot read wide receiver. Cause person who got to him was an extra Blitzer no fukk up by Brian winters.
But until stick with your biased opinions instead of admitting you like Geno
Negged.