I prefer the ergo feel of the pro vs the cradle. I bust out the cradle if I run the pro controller out and when playing 2 player. I think if you don't have it or can afford it than you can definitely survive without it but I think the grip / rumble is worth it.The pro controller isn’t a must in my opinion.....the joy con cradle works fine...for Mario you probably want to leave the joycon’s free anyway