NFL Week 12: What Have We Learned??!

[Ain't That Something]

Brock went from underrated to overrated. It's a good story and overall he's playing well but folk going overboard with the comparisons.

I would Take Purdy over Tua right now

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

The Purdy discussion is nasty...he's a solid QB who needs everything around him to be damn near perfect....and that's ok

That's why he's throwing dots with the pocket collapsing around him?

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

But even better, put Brock on Chicago's roster...put him in Carolina...are we still talking MVP? Is he taking them to the playoffs?

When did football become an individual sport?

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

its that even football-oriented folks have A LOT of issues separating the QB from a system. Fans have no idea and anyone claiming that they can separate a QB in a vacuum from their coaching and/or system, is just bullshytting.

You watch every Niner game as I do. You can witness the difference between a play that was drawn up so well that Deebo or Kittle is wide open with nobody within 10 yards of them and a play where the line collapses and Purdy has to improvise with his legs, elude defenders or when the pocket is breaking down still throws a dot on the money with anticipation... as he did to Aiyuk last night. That wasn't even SUPPOSED to go to Aiyuk originally.

Why are we pretending it's all the system? Because some idiots who don't watch Niner games are mad that people over "overrating" him? You want to please the non-watchers?

 

[King Biko]

I too think Dak is MVP at this point in the season.

Tyreek

 

[yseJ]

You watch every Niner game as I do. You can witness the difference between a play that was drawn up so well that Deebo or Kittle is wide open with nobody within 10 yards of them and a play where the line collapses and Purdy has to improvise with his legs, elude defenders or when the pocket is breaking down still throws a dot on the money with anticipation... as he did to Aiyuk last night. That wasn't even SUPPOSED to go to Aiyuk originally.

Why are we pretending it's all the system? Because some idiots who don't watch Niner games are mad that people over "overrating" him? You want to please the non-watchers?

I'm not though ?
Have you read my post ?

You know I like Brock a lot

My post was actually directed at people who say 'qb X is a system qb'. I dont think theres such a thing because most teams create around their qb strengths. its very difficult to take out qb by himself out of an offense and judge him alone. What you can do is analyze QB play as related to what theyre trying to do on offense - and Brock does so very well, just like you noted.

If anything my post was defending Brock lol

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

I'm not though ?
Have you read my post ?

You know I like Brock a lot

My post was actually directed at people who say 'qb X is a system qb'. I dont think theres such a thing because most teams create around their qb strengths. its very difficult to take out qb by himself out of an offense and judge him alone.

If anything my post was defending Brock lol

I can see how some QB's only flourish or are able to maintain in a certain system but Purdy has shown his has abilities that stretch beyond Shanny's playcalling or the talent around him.. That's all I'm saying.

I don't think most people in here commenting have seen half of the footage on Brock as we have.

 

[yseJ]

I can see how some QB's only flourish or are able to maintain in a certain system but Purdy has shown his has abilities that stretch beyond Shanny's playcalling or the talent around him.. That's all I'm saying.

I don't think most people in here commenting have seen half of the footage on Brock as we have.

yeah those people still thinking purdy just throws to wide open guys whom Shanny schemes open youre not gonna change their mind


I will say that those who are saying that purdy needs everything perfect around him to succeed, and the same people saying dak doesn't...are lying to themselves. we seen what happens to dak when he starts getting uncomfortable in the pocket

 

[JLova]

I would Take Purdy over Tua right now

I'm sure you would

Lions and dolphins pretty similar. Mediocre QBs proped up by great supporting cast. They beat down who they are supposed to beat but lose to elite teams

I don't agree at all, especially Tua.

 

[JLova]

I can see how some QB's only flourish or are able to maintain in a certain system but Purdy has shown his has abilities that stretch beyond Shanny's playcalling or the talent around him.. That's all I'm saying.

I don't think most people in here commenting have seen half of the footage on Brock as we have.

Have seen plenty of Brock. He's playing on an all star team. He's good too, but he's not as good as the number show.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Have seen plenty of Brock. He's playing on an all star team. He's good too, but he's not as good as the number show.

The right side of the line stinks. As a niner fan you should know that.

 

[JLova]

They quit because they have no faith in the offense. Not making a move for a QB once Rodgers went down told the defense they're not serious about winning this year. Starting Boyle really let them know.

Saleh got a raw deal. The front office did him no favors starting with all the terrible moves they made to acquire Rodgers. He should get another year because the only bright spot is the defense.

If that was Saleh's call I would have fired him for that mess, but seems like the call came above him.

 

[JLova]

The right side of the line stinks. As a niner fan you should know that.

As long as Trent is in, he fine.

 

[feelosofer]

I would Take Purdy over Tua right now

I think Tua is legit. He is a very smart and accurate QB. Purdy has the edge in intangibles and pocket presence but Tua is very solid.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

As long as Trent is in, he fine.

Trent sures up the left side, the right is terrible