It's you're
NBA Rank top 10 Center's ever
- Thread starter Jplaya2023
- Start date
Wouldn't say that, Malone was not someone you could dump the ball to and say "get me a bucket" on any given possession. Just wasn't the type of player he was, granted he compensated very well for a big with a lack of 1on1 skill.
Well I would. There is zero doubt in my mind that the 76ers would've won it all if you replaced Moses with D Rob. Would've played all time great level defense with his addition and next to Erving he'd have someone to take the alpha responsibility off his shoulders. Kareem at that stage of his career wasn't remotely close to what Hakeem was in '94, so we shouldn't just assume that the same scenario would play out.
D Rob put up 27/13/3/3 in his rookie year against the Nuggets (7th ranked defense) in the '90 PS. Swept the series. Hes got some pretty crazy series performances, just gets overshadowed by that asswhooping Vs Hakeem which wasn't helped by Rodman's refusal to play help defense.
Kareem #1 because he's got longevity, great prime/peak, postseason going for him, although I suppose you could use his mid-late 70s against him for postseason. Shaq, Hakeem, Wilt, Russell could be ranked in any order imo, really depends on what you value.
Robinson might have had the better peak but Malone wasn't far off and his longevity was just better, I'll take that. Ewing one of the GOAT ringless players, Mikan gets an old timer nod but if we're being honest he'd be terrible today but he's undoubtedly important to the game so there's that.
Walton had one of the best starts in league history and injuries are what prevented him from being a consensus top 10 C, I don't think he's as good as many claim but he's got an argument because of high peak/postseason play.
Robinson might have had the better peak but Malone wasn't far off and his longevity was just better, I'll take that. Ewing one of the GOAT ringless players, Mikan gets an old timer nod but if we're being honest he'd be terrible today but he's undoubtedly important to the game so there's that.
Walton had one of the best starts in league history and injuries are what prevented him from being a consensus top 10 C, I don't think he's as good as many claim but he's got an argument because of high peak/postseason play.
Black Lightning
Superstar
Robert Parish, Willis Reed, Wes Unseld, Nate Thurmond, Elvin Hayes, Walt Bellamy & Artist Gilmore were all better than Walton.
Last edited:
You mean like Steph Curry, Chris Paul, LeBron James, Kevin Durant, Dwyane Wade, etc., who all made the list from other positions?Why would any of the centers from this era be on the list, when their careers aren't even close to being over?
mbewane
Knicks: 93 til infinity
Just wanted to make sure Coward was nowhere near this discussion 
LIST IS COOL, ID PUT MACADOO OVER WALTON THO
Hakeem @ #5? Dream is easily 1 or 2.
Dream is easily 1 or 2.Hakeem @ #5?
if you were born after 1990 maybe
Maybe im the only one who always thought Ewing was slightly better then Robinson
I didn't even know that was an actual opinion.
It has nothing to do with "not having a ring". Everyone know Robinson was better than Ewing long before Robinson won a ring as a Kobe-like role player.
Ewing was the 1st-team all-NBA center ONCE. That's was Robinson's rookie year, in 89/90, when Ewing was a 27-year-old already in his fifth season.
Robinson surplanted him as the 1st-team All-NBA center in 90/91, his second season. Then again in 91/92. Also in 94/95 and 95/96.
If you look at their scoring numbers, they're bascally even. Ewing started playing younger and stretched out his peak to a little older, but the averages are the same and Robinson's 3 best seasons were better than Ewing's three best. But when you look at everything other than scoring....
Robinson's first 7 years, he got at least 12 rebounds/game four times. Ewing only did that once in his entire career.
Robinson's first 7 years, he got at least 2.5 assists/game six times. Ewing only did that two times his entire career.
Robinson's first 7 years, he got at least 3.2 blocks/game every year. Ewing only did that three times in his entire career.
Robinson's first 7 years, he got at least 1.4 steals/game every year. Ewing only did that two times in his entire career.
Robinson's first 7 years, he was 1st-team All-Defense four times. Ewing was NEVER 1st-team All-Defense.
Even if David Robinson retired at age 31 with just those 7 ears under his belt and no titles, he would have been understood as a guy who was better than Ewing. He was a better rebounder, better passer, better defender, and his equal as a scorer.
And even though his career was 3 years shorter, Robinson ended up with more career assists, offensive boards, steals, and blocks than Ewing, with FAR fewer fouls or turnovers and better shooting %. The only thing Ewing had over him for career numbers is defensive boards and points. And on the career averages Robinson has the advantage in literally everything.
Here are the 1st-team centers in Ewing's career:
Kareem
Olajuwon
Olajuwon
Olajuwon
Ewing
Robinson
Robinson
Olajuwon
Olajuwon
Robinson
Robinson
Olajuwon
Shaq
Shaq
Mourning
Shaq
Olajuwon, Robinson, and Shaq were clearly the three dominent centers of the 1990s, even before any of the three had gotten their titles.
