MJF Gave Bryan Danielson his first 5+ Star Match

[Raw Sauce]

I thought Mox/Hangman was very good and Bryan/MJF was great. I'd prolly go a bit lower on both matches since neither was flawless in the ring and neither had great builds but whatever (fukk going over 5*). Just don't act goofy if Roman vs Cody and/or Usos vs Sami & Owens delivers in Inglewood.

 

[NYChase718]

if you're gonna give that Hangman-Mox match 5 stars you're gonna have to go back and give Mick Foley about half a dozen 5 star matches in retrospect

Cane Meltzer

 

[PharaohAtem]

if you're gonna give that Hangman-Mox match 5 stars you're gonna have to go back and give Mick Foley about half a dozen 5 star matches in retrospect

Randy/Foley Backlash match would be 10 stars

 

[Finn Baller]

if I recall correctly that Hangman-Moxley match just got a better rating than any Kurt Angle match in history

 

[reserved_one]

if you're gonna give that Hangman-Mox match 5 stars you're gonna have to go back and give Mick Foley about half a dozen 5 star matches in retrospect

HHH vs Foley at Royal Rumble 2000 is rated lower than that (4.5 stars) and that match still holds the test of time.

These ratings he be giving out now to some of these matches be

 

[Raw Sauce]

if I recall correctly that Hangman-Moxley match just got a better rating than any Kurt Angle match in history

This statement alone invalidates Dave's entire star rating system

 

[Damnshow]

if I recall correctly that Hangman-Moxley match just got a better rating than any Kurt Angle match in history

Meltzer thinks two talentless dudes hitting each other with objects is considered an exciting must see professional wrestling. This guy is a mark.

 

[Novembruh]

moxley/page getting a 5 invalidates the whole system; argue witcha mama

 

[VegetasHairline]

Dave Meltzer is the @R=G of wrestling!

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

The ratings ain't shyt lol he even said himself he laughs when people start conversations around them. So of course he's going to keep doing it.

That said.. I'm not sure what I would have rated Hangman vs. Moxley. Anyone on here saying it wasn't engaging is a liar or a stooge.. I just don't know what I'd actually rate it.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Meltzer thinks two talentless dudes hitting each other with objects is considered an exciting must see professional wrestling. This guy is a mark.

It was engaging. Stop crying about it Everyone in the thread was having a great time watching it including people who never fukk with AEW

 

[Damnshow]

It was engaging. Stop crying about it Everyone in the thread was having a great time watching it including people who never fukk with AEW

It was engaging - 5 stars, this is awesome, this is awesome!

 

[mattw1313]

Mox has a 5 star match

The hate is going to be delicious

that cracked out cac will give anything in aew 5 Stars

 

[Hey_zeus]

Nigel vs Brine>>>>>

 

[Cattle Mutilation]

Can't believe we have people in 2023 still getting worked over star ratings. fukking marks