yeah like i said booker was clearly the best color commentator they've had in years. he didn't even have to do goofy fake forced heel shyt, he was just entertaining, but i never had an issue with percy watson, same with otunga/saxton
i don't think they were/are great, but they weren't any worse than the white dudes doing it. all of the commentators are boring and castrated by wwe's shytty standards and rules.
i did think coachman sucked, but i think that was more because he was lazy and didn't know shyt about the product. i don't remember him being as objectively bad in the mid 2000s as he was when he came back. i think he was just bitter he lost his job in legit sports and had to come back to wrestling and didn't take it serious.
meltzer really shouldn't talk though because he the main one pushing his buddy alex marvez who was literally a huge DUD at the AEW show.