Melo: I'm the most underrated star

[FS4LFE]

Ppl say this as if it's facts

we will see in due time..

Well it all depends on Rose. But I'd bet on Rose over the Knicks roster.

 

[JerseyFinest!]

Well it all depends on Rose. But I'd bet on Rose over the Knicks roster.

we will see
But Melo deal is for 5 years, not just a season
what has the Bulls FO done to make anybody confident in them

 

[charmander]

Is he lying? How many passes Chris Paul get?

hawks fans were comparing him to Josh Smith on here that's how absurd some of these people are.

josh smith is much more well rounded and a way better defensive player than melo

if his jumper wasn't broke it wouldn't even be a contest

 

[onelastdeath]

I didn't say he would have won a ring if he went to the Bulls. I said he would have a significantly better chance if he did.

How? explain that to me.

 

[FS4LFE]

How? explain that to me.

The bulls roster > the Knicks roster.

 

[onelastdeath]

The bulls roster > the Knicks roster.

How? Let's keep a couple of things a buck

for one. If Melo would have gone, then Taj would have to leave, and they would not have had Pau. Because a sign and trade would have been the only way Melo would have been able to go.

SO you're looking at

PG: Rose (No one knows if he will stay healthy, and has looked bad)
SG: Butler
SF:Melo
PF: (???) Boozer gone.
C: Joakim

ADD to the fact that they would have been cap hostage with Rose being paid what he is. Joakim, and Melo. So no added help.

Knicks will have Bargs and Stat off the book this year, in a pretty deep FA class. Where is the better chance? long term or short term?

 

[FS4LFE]

How? Let's keep a couple of things a buck

for one. If Melo would have gone, then Taj would have to leave, and they would not have had Pau. Because a sign and trade would have been the only way Melo would have been able to go.

SO you're looking at

PG: Rose (No one knows if he will stay healthy, and has looked bad)
SG: Butler
SF:Melo
PF: (???) Boozer gone.
C: Joakim

ADD to the fact that they would have been cap hostage with Rose being paid what he is. Joakim, and Melo. So no added help.

Knicks will have Bargs and Stat off the book this year, in a pretty deep FA class. Where is the better chance? long term or short term?

So you think it's a debate as to who has the better supporting case between the Knicks and the Bulls?

 

[onelastdeath]

So you think it's a debate as to who has the better supporting case between the Knicks and the Bulls?

Absolutely. The biggest variable is the assumption that Rose will

A) Stay Healthy
B) Return to being the 2011 top 2 Player MVP

If Rose goes down again this year ( )

Bulls are right back where they started.

If Rose stays healthy and returns to form then theres no debate. But he hasnt stayed healthy, and he hasnt looked anything like his former self.

That's a big gamble to ask a man to do. 42 million dollar paycut, AND no promise of your wingman retaining his health.

It'd be one thing if Rose had been looking like his 2011 self, and had no history of injuries, but he's played what? 20 something games in the last 2 seasons?

 

[Urahara_Kisuke]

Earlier this week, he said he was motivated to return to New York, in part, due to "unfinished business."

 

[Rice N Beans]

Please take a moment to admire the great Carmelo Anthony:

* 0 Rings
* 0 Finals Appearances
* 0 Finals MVP's, 0 Full Season MVP's
* 0 All Star Game MVP's
* 0 Time All NBA 1st Team
* 0 All Defensive teams
* 3 playoff series wins in 11 years
* 8 first round playoff series losses
* 23-43 career playoff record (worst all time for any player)
* 41% shooter for his career in the playoffs
* 1-17 while playing for the Knicks on game winning shot attempts in the 4th quarter & OT
* 37% shooting in the 4th quarters of games last season


:nylost: #tnt

Didn't realize he had it this bad breh.

 

[Mr. Jack Napier]

josh smith is much more well rounded and a way better defensive player than melo

if his jumper wasn't broke it wouldn't even be a contest

And this is why nobody takes Hawks fans seriously.

 

[ExodusNirvana]

That's my Small Forward

TELL EM!!!!

 

[Shadow King]

He's underrated and overrated.
Phil's moves in 2015 will determine if Melo gets a ring or not.

 

[Big Boss]

tbh, melo isn't underrated

 

[61 Corpses]

Please take a moment to admire the great Carmelo Anthony:

* 0 Rings
* 0 Finals Appearances
* 0 Finals MVP's, 0 Full Season MVP's
* 0 All Star Game MVP's
* 0 Time All NBA 1st Team
* 0 All Defensive teams
* 3 playoff series wins in 11 years
* 8 first round playoff series losses
* 23-43 career playoff record (worst all time for any player)
* 41% shooter for his career in the playoffs
* 1-17 while playing for the Knicks on game winning shot attempts in the 4th quarter & OT
* 37% shooting in the 4th quarters of games last season


:nylost: #tnt

The following error occurred:
You must spread reputation to at least 30 other user(s) before you can give reputation to Detroit Wave again.