Absolutely love this trilogy, but it's definitely not perfect.
Never try to watch all the extended versions. Them shyts are too fukking long. Return of the King is the weakest one to me. Theatrical felt too long, and thr end(s) felt like Jackson was more checking off boxes to say he got everything in an/or keep the Tolkien family happy for trying to stay close to the books.
Worth the price of admission for the Moria and Helm's Deep sequences alone.
.......and like an idiot, I'm eye fukking the UHD rereleases that are about to come out to replace my blu ray set.