Lets be Reality, fukk choreographed dunking. The best in-game dunker of all time...
- Thread starter gho3st
- Start date
OP MAKES AN EXCELLENT POINT
Mike
Kemp
Nique
Carter
Kemp
Nique
Carter
Jesus Is Lord
Give Thanks, Repent, and Forgive
They've already been posted, but see below since you're requiring redundancy.
Here are 5 of Kobe's best in-game dunks (not a consensus top 5, but they're in his archive - I'm well aware of others including the reverse at the Garden & the one over Nash):
Here are 5 of Vince's (not including his double pump reverse alley pop, windmill off the backboard - for the last clip, it's #4, I couldn't find the individual video):
Vince supersedes him in leaping ability, explosiveness, power, body control against defenders, and how he manipulates the ball in the air. Kobe did demonstrate more uniqueness with his 270 behind the back & his alley-oop on the other side of the rim, but Vince has had better 'oops.
Keep in mind none of this is to diminish Kobe's ability - I have him at #3 all time. But compare any of his windmills to Vince's windmills and the Vince's form is untouchable, in addition to everything above.
The whole point of debating is to learn more about other perspectives - I replied to everything you said, and you in turn simply skimmed through it & paraphrased. If you choose not to read beyond what you want to, then there's not much more I can say
There was nothing for you to really say after your second post, especially after I said that if you thought Vince is the best that you'd get no argument from me, but you felt the need to FINALLY back up your claims, which got no argument from me in the first place. If you chose to understand that your opinion isn't the end all and others feel different about Vince, then you'd stop typing paragraphs like you're dropping facts. Now make sure YOU don't skim over this again.....if YOU feel that Vince is the best, you'll get no argument from ME. Now post to someone who opposes your OPINION, not me.
They've already been posted, but see below since you're requiring redundancy.
Here are 5 of Kobe's best in-game dunks (not a consensus top 5, but they're in his archive - I'm well aware of others including the reverse at the Garden & the one over Nash):
Here are 5 of Vince's (not including his double pump reverse alley pop, windmill off the backboard - for the last clip, it's #4, I couldn't find the individual video):
Vince supersedes him in leaping ability, explosiveness, power, body control against defenders, and how he manipulates the ball in the air. Kobe did demonstrate more uniqueness with his 270 behind the back & his alley-oop on the other side of the rim, but Vince has had better 'oops.
Keep in mind none of this is to diminish Kobe's ability - I have him at #3 all time. But compare any of his windmills to Vince's windmills and the Vince's form is untouchable, in addition to everything above.
The whole point of debating is to learn more about other perspectives - I replied to everything you said, and you in turn simply skimmed through it & paraphrased. If you choose not to read beyond what you want to, then there's not much more I can say
you are agreeing with what i said. VINCE OUT JUMPS kobe. yeah we know that. and vince to me may just beat out my favorite nique dunks of all time when it comes to just hammering on fools heads. But we're talking PURE STYLE. Kobe had better STYLE then vince. which is why his dunks cant be duplicated(at least have not been duplicated in game as of yet...we're talking about the stylish dunks). he's dunked on everyone so thats not what i'm talking about either and again i will always prefer vince yamming on ZO or jumping over a grown a... 7 foot man vs kobe dunking over yao ming(which is still very impressive). but thats not the discussion. its about STYLE/Uniqueness. Kobe has that above vince. sorry to tell you.
Demonic Jenkins
Pro
You have to be seriously delusional to think kobe is a better in game dunker than vince carter lol....like seriously wtf is wrong with this dudes eyes?
Demonic Jenkins
Pro
Vince....Blake....kemp.....all better in game Dunkers than kobe....and that's just off top
Theodoresolderbreh
No Shorts No Malarkey
this is a great thread i take no side in this battle 
Cerebral Labyrinth
All Star
I didn't agree with you at all. Read my post again, I'm not talking about just dunks over defenders. In general, Vince's in-game dunks are much better than Kobe's. I said Kobe has demonstrated more uniqueness on a few dunks. And yes it's about style, Vince's style due to his explosiveness, overall variety and what he's able to do with the ball mid-air make him superior to Kobe as an in-game dunker.
I have no idea what's wrong with all these cats in this thread. The difference is clear as day. But then, this just goes to show that some opinions are certainly worth more than others.
Man fukk Style you androgynous ass nikkasno they were not better. you FELT they were better because you saw someone get banged on. so it gives you that extrafactor.
But what kobe did was and still has not been duplicated in game. thats called STYLE. something the VC over weiss dunk didnt have, nor did the zo dunk have. both of those dunks was about a man out jumping another man. the weiss dunk was "i can jump higher then anyone" dunk. again as lovely as that was. and best in Game DUNKED ON dunk of all time. its not the most STYLISH dunk of all time in a game.
people need to take Kobe out of this thread.
he was a great player but nowhere near an all time dunker.
if you have kobes dunks in here you might as well put scottie pippens dunks. or tracy mcgrady. or even my dude wade.
not saying they are wack, they are great dunkers, but they're arent THE GREAT dunker.
These guys have all done a nice tomahawk posterization on a 7footer in their primes.
But were talking about nikkas who posterized people with standing dunks, or reverse double clutch two handers.
not on a fastbreak, just out the post. Nique made the putback his signature move. did that shyt everygame.
show me a clip of any of these guys doing a standing windmill. no running no steps, just straight up windmill with D on you.
Nique are in a whole nother stratosphere.
he was a great player but nowhere near an all time dunker.
if you have kobes dunks in here you might as well put scottie pippens dunks. or tracy mcgrady. or even my dude wade.
not saying they are wack, they are great dunkers, but they're arent THE GREAT dunker.
These guys have all done a nice tomahawk posterization on a 7footer in their primes.
But were talking about nikkas who posterized people with standing dunks, or reverse double clutch two handers.
not on a fastbreak, just out the post. Nique made the putback his signature move. did that shyt everygame.
show me a clip of any of these guys doing a standing windmill. no running no steps, just straight up windmill with D on you.
Nique are in a whole nother stratosphere.
Idk who said it but someone keeps emphasizing how no one has duplicated Kobe's in game dunks.... well I haven't seen anyone jumping over 7 ft nikkas since Vince Carter did it so that hasn't been duplicated either