Keep Justin Fields or draft a new QB?

If you in charge who is the Bears QB in 2024?

  • Fields

  • Caleb

  • Maye

  • Penix

  • Other prospect


Results are only viewable after voting.

Th3G3ntleman

Superstar
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
14,445
Reputation
-2,802
Daps
52,826
Reppin
NULL
This isn't what you think the Bears will do. This is a what would you do. Let's put some names to these bullets. I think you take the new QB(Caleb) and use your own pick on a playmaker.
 

Controversy

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2015
Messages
12,713
Reputation
-413
Daps
33,785
Reppin
Philly
If you're the bears you have to risk missing out on Marv to acquire multiple FRPs. Odunze is not a bad consolation prize if you have to trade 4 or lower.

You roll with fields and build an elite offense around him. Draft an OL at 10.

Dream scenario - Trade back to 3, draft Marv, pick up an extra first rounder

Marv is not getting past AZ at 4
 

jay211

Superstar
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
15,853
Reputation
1,459
Daps
44,259
Reppin
NULL
I'd keep Fields, talk to the Commanders to trade down to 2, pick up another 2nd and a 4th, draft MHJ. The Bears seem to have rallied behind Fields


That's exactly what I'd do. Except my trade down price would be The Commanders number 1 (2024), their number 2 (2024), their number 1 (2025), and Mclaurin. Then I'd draft Marvin Harrison Jr, and a bunch of defensive studs and an o-lineman.
 

Th3G3ntleman

Superstar
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
14,445
Reputation
-2,802
Daps
52,826
Reppin
NULL
That's exactly what I'd do. Except my trade down price would be The Commanders number 1 (2024), their number 2 (2024), their number 1 (2025), and Mclaurin. Then I'd draft Marvin Harrison Jr, and a bunch of defensive studs and an o-lineman.

I doubt you can get a haul like that. I feel like the other teams who could trade up probably know that this is a bit of a bind for the Bears in a way.
 
Joined
May 11, 2012
Messages
34,071
Reputation
9,357
Daps
103,688
Reppin
NULL
If you're the bears you have to risk missing out on Marv to acquire multiple FRPs. Odunze is not a bad consolation prize if you have to trade 4 or lower.

You roll with fields and build an elite offense around him. Draft an OL at 10.

Dream scenario - Trade back to 3, draft Marv, pick up an extra first rounder

Marv is not getting past AZ at 4
The dumb azz Cardinals might beat the Seahawks at home this week.
 

RubioTheCruel

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Jul 16, 2013
Messages
20,368
Reputation
2,089
Daps
76,910
Reppin
Brooklyn, NY
That's exactly what I'd do. Except my trade down price would be The Commanders number 1 (2024), their number 2 (2024), their number 1 (2025), and Mclaurin. Then I'd draft Marvin Harrison Jr, and a bunch of defensive studs and an o-lineman.
That's way too much to surrender for the Commanders to move from 2 to 1. They can just call your bluff and draft another QB
 

Remote

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 29, 2013
Messages
78,028
Reputation
23,671
Daps
355,260
100% draft a new QB.
Justin Fields is athletic but he's not accurate enough and hasn't shown the ability to dissect defenses enough to be a consistent winner.

The issue is that the Bears have already committed to Eberflus going forward so if they draft a new QB, you have to assume Eberflus has a longer leash. I'm not sure if that's a good or bad thing.
 

GoldenGlove

😐😑😶😑😐
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
58,199
Reputation
5,496
Daps
137,232
100% draft a new QB.
Justin Fields is athletic but he's not accurate enough and hasn't shown the ability to dissect defenses enough to be a consistent winner.

The issue is that the Bears have already committed to Eberflus going forward so if they draft a new QB, you have to assume Eberflus has a longer leash. I'm not sure if that's a good or bad thing.
The Flus earned another year with how the team rebounded and the defense performed. They should move on from Getsy and get a new OC IMO tho.
 
Top