Just finished Uncharted 3...

[The Frozen One]

UC2 from the second you played had this feeling to it. As soon as you play the first chapter, you can see the masterpiece that the game is.

Then it just builds on that. The action, the set pieces, the characters. Everything is done in such a way that it's so hard not to like the game.

Then came the train scene, and that cemented UC2 as one of the greatest of all time.

UC3 followed the same formula and failed miserably. There was too much of plot holes, breaks in the storyline, action for the sake of being action, and just not as polished as UC2 was. You can clearly see that the amount of time spent in UC2 was not the same as in UC3. The game starts off flat, gets good, then falls flat again. It's like a bad roller coaster ride.

UC2 definitely takes the cake. UC3 just felt rushed and unpolished.

 

[Boolean]

is all this shade about UC3 coming from

if UC2 is a 10 UC3 is 9.5 only because UC2 came first

calling UC3 unpolished when that shyt was longer, had a better story AND was more action packed

 

[Regular_P]

could they port abyss to ps3 ?

Probably, but with the Vita struggling, i doubt Sony would let them do it anytime soon.

 

[Clapsteel O'Neal]

is all this shade about UC3 coming from

if UC2 is a 10 UC3 is 9.5 only because UC2 came first

calling UC3 unpolished when that shyt was longer, had a better story AND was more action packed

is was unpolished though

the movement, and movement detection regressed from UC2 to UC3


UC3 didn't even have a legit 'last boss'


I do agree UC3 obvs was more action packed but it did get to a point where it was gimmicky (i will say though that the part where you'll falling out of the plane, when the ship is sinking upside down and running from the collapsing building at gaming moments)


To me, UC2 is just a more complete experience

UC1 I feel had the best platforming, UC2 had a balance between action and platforming and UC3 had the best action


UC1 - 4/5
UC2 - 5/5
UC3 - 4.5/5

 

[trollol]

Another thing that bothered me was the total disconnect between the story and gameplay. In the story Drake seems like a nice fairly normal dude, who cares about his life and the life of others. In the gameplay he turns into Rambo, and mowes down thousands of enemies.

agree with this, but with this type of game you gotta suspend some expectation for reality

drake's kill count is in the thousands

if UC3 came before UC2, it wouldve been hailed a near classic, but anything after the epicness of 2 was gonna fall short

 

[trollol]

I find it hilarious that people say this when 2 had no fukkin story.


Story was generic as fuk. If u were impressed by UC2s weak story then ur mind will be blown when u get around to playing MGS3 or Assassins Creed II


Storywise/Gameplay/Epic moments UC3 >>> UC2


UC3s epic moments are huger and outnumber those found in UC2, is this not a fact?


The hand to hand combat in UC3 is superior to the simple sh1t that was in UC2, is this not a fact?


And the story is not even debatable, UC2 was ur typical treasure hunter generic sh1t, no different than the first game. UC3 went into the backstory and history of it's characters which made you connect with them more than u had did before.


I don't really see how anyone who has played all 3 games can say otherwise. Only thing that was kinda off was the pacing at the beginning but it is forgiven because its used to build the story.


I don't know if u folks are just giving honest opinions or just following what other ppl have said. Never underestimate the power of influence, especially on younger people. Its how trends start and the reason why many of u n1glets were running around with baggy pants, XXXL tees just 5 yrs ago and are now rocking skinny jeans and smedium v necks.


I don't think you people really think for yourself .............to be honest

nah, you're reading too much into it. both games are piff, just a matter of preference

the pacing in 2 was better imo... the storyline might not have had the backstory into in, but it was a lot funnier, and i def cared about the characters more and kept guessing how it was gonna end. 3 had some missing pieces and the ending felt rushed and anti-climatic

gotta remember that when 2 came out, it was nonstop compared to 1

 

[Jone2three45]

i preferred 3 to 2.


game had more epic moments, UC2 had epic moments but not nearly as many as UC3


The entire ship part alone sh1ts on everything in UC2, not to mention the part where ur jumping from horse, to car, to horse and back to car again, all the while bussing ur guns


But I guess saying UC2 is better is just the popular thing to say, dunno if its just a meme or not.


To each his own tho

 

[Jone2three45]

UC2>UC1>UC3

UC3 story had the potential to be great, but the game fell off and was short compared to the others. So many loopholes in that game,
UC1 had the better villains.
UC2, overall was the better game. In fact it is a top 10 game of this gen. I enjoyed this incarnation the most.