Joe Montana is still the best QB ever

J

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
42,908
Reputation
-244
Daps
89,027
BLAZO da GAWD said:
oh of course :jawalrus:

u want me to post reg season stats too or does only the post season count to the Montana brigade :dwillhuh:

GOAT QB encompasses everything. If u wanna say Montana is the GOAT playoff QB, I won't even argue with you about that. But Brady has as much claim to the GOAT title if you considering postseason and regular season achievements
Click to expand...

The NFL changed the rules to make it easier for QB's today. So posting regular season numbers please keep in mind the difference in the rules today as it was 20 years ago.

Please be fair and consider that
 
BLAZO da GAWD

BLAZO da GAWD

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
9,093
Reputation
1,460
Daps
18,141
Reppin
NEW ERA
Jplaya2023 said:
The NFL changed the rules to make it easier for QB's today. So posting regular season numbers please keep in mind the difference in the rules today as it was 20 years ago.

Please be fair and consider that
Click to expand...

didn't Marino throw 48 touchdowns in like '84 throwing to receivers u cant even name without googling? :dwillhuh:

then 30 touchdowns the year after

then 44 the year after that

:dwillhuh:

no excuse :lolbron:
 
J

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
42,908
Reputation
-244
Daps
89,027
BLAZO da GAWD said:
didn't Marino throw 48 touchdowns in like '84 throwing to receivers u cant even name without googling? :dwillhuh:

then 30 touchdowns the year after

then 44 the year after that

:dwillhuh:

no excuse :lolbron:
Click to expand...

Dan Marino didn't have the team and balance Montana had. Marino would throw 60 td's today.

Now name me other QB's from that era throwing 44 and 48 TD's. Dan was a statistical outlier, certainly not the norm
 
Saysumthinfunnymike

Saysumthinfunnymike

VOTE!!!
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
188,542
Reputation
24,617
Daps
611,052
Reppin
49ers..Braves..Celtics
BLAZO da GAWD said:
But Brady has as much claim to the GOAT title if you considering postseason and regular season achievements
Click to expand...

1989 season Montana starts 13 games and has a QB rating of 112.4. Young started the other 3 games. The team was 14-2. Montana attempted 386 passes.

Brady's best year was 2007. You know how many passes he attempted that year? 578. He's thrown over 600 passes in a season 3 times and over 500 passes five other times.

It's a different game and the 49ers were always more of a balanced attack. The Pats have been a throw first team for at least the last six years.

:manny:
 
J

Jplaya2023

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
42,908
Reputation
-244
Daps
89,027
saysumthinfunnymike said:
1989 season Montana starts 13 games and has a QB rating of 112.4. Young started the other 3 games. The team was 14-2. Montana attempted 386 passes.

Brady's best year was 2007. You know how many passes he attempted that year? 578. He's thrown over 600 passes in a season 3 times and over 500 passes five other times.

It's a different game and the 49ers were always more of a balanced attack. The Pats have been a throw first team for at least the last six years.

:manny:
Click to expand...

Exactly, we had balance, solid backs, Craig and Rathman, and a scheme predicated on short passes to the flats and the backs. We wasn't running a hyper no no huddle all game long.

Brady will have an edge stat's wise, hell manning, brees, gawdgers, etc.. will have better regular season stats that Montana as well no question. But it's more to that
 
BLAZO da GAWD

BLAZO da GAWD

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
9,093
Reputation
1,460
Daps
18,141
Reppin
NEW ERA
Jplaya2023 said:
Dan Marino didn't have the team and balance Montana had. Marino would throw 60 td's today.

Now name me other QB's from that era throwing 44 and 48 TD's. Dan was a statistical outlier, certainly not the norm
Click to expand...

agreed. however there were a couple of QB's in that era that put up 30TD seasons, in line with what Montana was putting up. some are guys we've never even heard of
 
the next guy

the next guy

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
39,958
Reputation
1,579
Daps
38,182
Reppin
NULL
Brady and Peyton are too flawed


Joe Cool >>>>>>>>>>>>>. Brady cares more about being a supermodel, peyton is a loudmouth choker.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top