‘It’s Very Easy’: Trans Activist Tells MSNBC Democrats Can ‘Fight Back’ and Win on Trans Issues, ‘Science is On Our Side’;

[Westbama Heartthrob]

Sex is binary. Disorders don’t change that.

Why dont transgender biological males in the west become conservative muslim women in burkas? This entire trans debate is a sociological voluntary endeavor that displaces people with real medical disorders. On top of that, no one you have defended that has been transgender has any of these disorders.

The conversation includes everyone. I'm not equating trans people's experience to someone with swyer syndrome. I'm just using the latter as the most clear example of how not everyone fits nearly into male or female

Which shouldn't be hard to understand but political reasons rear their heads I see

Dismissing being trans as a mental illness is just straight up incorrect. Find me a reputable source that says gender dyphoria is a mental illness

I'm sure it's right next to the proof you're black

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

The conversation includes everyone. I'm not equating trans people's experience to someone with swyer syndrome.

Yes you are. Thats why yall keep using the rarest genetic disorders to defend the person this thread was started around defending their adult-age transition as equivalent to a congenital disorder.

I'm just using the latter as the most clear example of how not everyone fits nearly into male or female

Gender is sociological. Sex is biological. Wanting to mimic the other sex based on socialized norms doesn’t make you a member of that sex.

Which shouldn't be hard to understand but political reasons rear their heads I see

Dismissing being trans as a mental illness is just straight up incorrect. Find me a reputable source that says gender dyphoria is a mental illness

I'm sure it's right next to the proof you're black

Transgenderism is costume design with a diagnosis.

 

[bnew]

Why are you using RARE genetic disorders to defend the majority of transgenders? They are still genetically MALE, but lack physical characteristics.

Yall keep doing this.

Its dishonest.

dismissing facts of reality is dishonest.

you stated positions are not universal truths.

 

[TAYLONDO SAMSWORTHY]

If Dems care about Trans rights so much, they need to actively denounce the issues that lose elections, then help them nikkas out after they win.

U cant torpedo your campaign by promoting shyt that majority of voters fear/dislike that only benefits 0.5% of the population

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

dismissing facts of reality is dishonest.

you stated positions are not universal truths.

The trans lobby attempted to crush any scientific and medical and political dissent until it crumbled under the weight of their own contradictions.

This is a house cards and its already begun to crash.

Transgenderism isn’t a real condition.

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

@Westbama Heartthrob You can’t out-science, the science guy

 

[Westbama Heartthrob]

Gender is sociological. Sex is biological. Wanting to mimic the other sex based on socialized norms doesn’t make you a member of that

True. But it's not mimicry for trans people. Its their gender identity whether you agree or disagree

And if norms are socialized, that means they're subject to change with time. So don't that invalidate gender being a binary as well?

If not gender affirming care, what do you have as an alternative with evidence to support it'll actually work

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

True. But it's not mimicry for trans people. Its their gender identity whether you agree or disagree

Mimicking the most hyperbolic stereotypes of the other sex in socially derived settings is not “gender identity”.

its cosplay.

And if norms are socialized, that means they're subject to change with time. So don't that invalidate gender being a binary as well?

Gender isn’t a real thing. It’s just the sociology of sex in different environments. Thats how you get “butch” lesbians and barbie doll feminists and everything in between. Displacing women isn’t “pro-women”

If not gender affirming care, what do you have as an alternative with evidence to support it'll actually work

Stop telling people being trans is legitimate for the first part. It’s no different than religious people spreading faith in their body via a set of rituals and sacrificial commitments to demonstrate fealty. Condition people to accept who they are, but not they can chop and remix themselves into what they will never be.

Gender dysphoria is the real disorder, not the condition to be coddled.

 

[Westbama Heartthrob]

Stop telling people being trans is legitimate for the first part. It’s no different than religious people spreading faith in their body via a set of rituals and sacrificial commitments to demonstrate fealty. Condition people to accept who they are, but not they can chop and remix themselves into what they will never be.

Gender dysphoria is the real disorder, not the condition to be coddled.

Color me shocked. A plan i'm sure no one ever tried before

Just tell them they're delusional and problem solved

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

Color me shocked. A plan i'm sure no one ever tried before

Just tell them they're delusional and problem solved

Condoning them and coddling them is how you got youths undergoing double mastectomies and getting hormone treatments

 

[Westbama Heartthrob]

Condoning them and coddling them is how you got youths undergoing double mastectomies and getting hormone treatments

There you go bringing up RARE instances to defend the erasure of trans people

Am I doing it right?

 

[☑︎#VoteDemocrat]

There you go bringing up RARE instances to defend the erasure of trans people

Am I doing it right?

Nah. You dont get to do that. Trans activists wanted to broaden access to those procedures.

People do not want to expand RARE disorders.