It's time to UPDATE that P4P list :)

[GREENandYELLOW]

Bradley's 2014 was seriously underwhelming and JMM's was even worse.

Sounds like JMM may be close to retiring...I hadn't officially heard anything here, but Dan reported he is recovering from a knee injury.
I think JMM is slowly winding down his career.

I wish Bradley would have had a 3rd fight in 2014...but I can't be too hard on him. He lost to Pacquiao, who is a top 3 PFP (if you include Ward when he is active) and he deserved a clear decision victory vs. Chavez. He looked good in that fight and I thought he looked better doing it than both Rios and Thurman. I am #Thurminators all the way, but Bradley boxed him better than Thurman did and if Bradley remotely had the power that Thurman does, it wouldn't have gone the distance.

 

[GREENandYELLOW]

Why? The only person Bradley has ever lost to was #2 P4P Manny Pacquiao, and the only person JMM has lost to in the last 9 years who wasnt ATGs in Floyd/Manny was an undefeated P4P Prime Tim Bradley. Other than that, he's beaten everyone. Plus they both have W's over Manny.


Nobody underneath them have the recent resumes that they have

I should say, I don't agree with Bradley's W over Manny. I put that in the Max Kellerman comment category of just because a fighter gets a W, you can mentally change it and judge a fighter by your opinion. The record book may say Bradley beat Pacquiao, but he has two L's vs. him in my book.

It doesn't hurt his PFP rating though (I judge him off the 2 L's anyways). He lost to the #2 or #3 PFP fighter in the world, no shame in that. Already see this playing out in Mayweather vs. Pacquiao discusssions. Fans of one side want to put down the other side. Why? You should hype up the other side, it makes your W all the more impressive. Either way, I think it is pretty much indisputable that Floyd and Manny are two of the top PFP fighters. A win should cement that fighters legacy forever and mean they deserve that #1 crown. A loss means that fighter fought the best opponent available and an all time great, in many respects it helps your resume. But if (when) Floyd or Manny loses vs. each other, are people really going to say the loser deserves to drop out of the top 10? At this point both fighters have cemented their legacy. The fight vs. each other really just determines how their legacy vs. each other will be settled.

 

[dem bath salts]

Floydie
Manny
Wlad
Ward
Rigo
Kovalev
GGG
Swift
Saul
Inoue

 

[FukkaPaidEmail]

1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Andre Ward (Could easily be 1 if the nikka actually fought anywhere else outside of courtrooms)
4.Roman Gonzalez
5. Wlad
6. Rigo
7.Kovalev
8. Tim Bradley
9. GGG
10. Terrence Crawford

 

[FreedMind]

Man a Marquez Brook fight in Estadio Azteca would have been a crazy event wish it could have been made.

Edit: my bad for the off topic..

 

[Thatrogueassdiaz]

What about him? He damn sure shouldn't even be mentioned in a Top 10 P4P; that much I do know about Peter Quillin.

And I updated my list in the main thread:
1. Floyd Mayweather
2. Manny Pacquiao
3. Wladimir Klitschko
4. Sergey Kovalev
5. Gillermo Rogondeaux
6. Roman Gonzalez
7. Canelo Alvarez
8. Gennady Golovkin
9. Tim Bradley
10.Terrence Crawford

This is probably what my list would be as well

 

[HARLEM AL]

I'm just that son of Goosen ain't on it...

 

[TheNig]

I'm just that son of Goosen ain't on it...

No tie? nikka don't tell me what to do. You ain't my daddy.

1. Sergey
2. Floyd
3. Manny
4. Wlad
5. GGG
6. Roman G
7. Rigo
8. Canelo
9. Ward
10. T Craw

 

[Mook]

No, just there's a lot of names and places to put people. Top 5 is hella easy. Like where am I going to put Marquez and Bradley and other fighter's who are interchangable from 5-10? What about someone like Gonzalez who should be top 5? What about Peter Quillin? I mean it's just too hard.

Btw fukk you fakkit.

Go watch mma fekket

 

[Thatrogueassdiaz]

Go watch mma fekket

Never that, fakkit

 

[mr. smoke weed]

Floyd
manny
wlad
rigo
ward
timmy
sergei
roman g
GGG
Swift
Canelo
T Craw

 

[#SOG_soldier]

1. Ward (dont give a fukk if he never fights again. im putting him at the #1 spot)
2. Wlad
3. Floyd
4. Manny
5. Rigo
6. Roman
7. Krusher
8. GGG
9. TC (might be too low)
10.Froch ( i think he would beat GGG doe )


Before you nikkas say something yes Im biased as fukk

 

[WhodatWhoadi]

Updated in main thread.

 

[Black_Jesus]

Delete

 

[Mac Casper]

Here's your definitive list

1. Floyd Mayweather Jr.
2. Wladimir Klitschko - how long has he dominated this division, an eventual win over Deontay WIlder or Tyson Fury would continue to solidify this
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Roman Gonzalez - 42-0, just 27 years old . . very exciting to watch, once Arum picks him up to exploit the Nicaragua market you'll hear about him more. From a technical standpoint this guy is ready to dominate for years to come
5. Gennady Golovkin - maybe a bit premature for 5 spot but Wally Russell is seeing down the road . . he keeps an active schedule and he's exhibiting pure dominance
6. Guillermo Rigondeux -
7. Sergey Kovalev
8. Carl Froch - would eventually like to see him take on GGG
9. Juan Manuel Marquez
10. Deontay Wilder