Is Paolo Banchero good enough to dig the Magic out the grave?

Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
84,805
Reputation
9,276
Daps
229,287
think its a bit disingenuous to compare him to julius
this guy came out of college with vision, tighter handle, a midpost game, and range from 3. while also being taller, more explosive and just in general better shape.
literally he comes into the league playing near or better than PEAK julius randle of 2 years ago...which took julius 7 years to get to.
if someone enters the league doing practically everything better than another player who took more than half a decade to reach is it fair to even compare them.
thats like saying steph curry is a good version of mahmoud rauf. at some point if the differences are so pronounced off rip...it's a different animal entirely
See:
An apt comparison has already been made - the Good version of Julius Randle. They're pretty much identical twins. One good, one evil.
Randle at his absolute best was last year 25/11/5 i dont think banchero gets there....i like the David Lee comp a decent scorer with limited range who will score on mismatches,bad defender but wont be the m ain guy on an elite team...when you think about thats a perfect comp...
Banchero doesn't need to get to 25, 11 and 5 to be better than Julius, as those are meaningless box score numbers that were an anomaly, played during a season with no crowds (there's a reason why he hasn't been able to replicate them in any manner, in any other season). I say he's the good to Julius' evil because he plays in a more impactful manner - he's not selfish by purely accumulating volume stats to make himself look better on paper than he does irl. Julius has managed to fool a lot of folks who look at his surface stats and mistake that for him being a good player, when he doesn't expend energy for actions that aren't in the box score.

He's incapable of playing winning basketball. That's why he's evil.

Their size, athleticism and styles of play are nearly identical:

- They're both big body tweeners (6'9"-6'10"; 240lbs-250lbs)
- Their primary diet of offense is under-the-rim bully ball (while both have above-average athleticism, they're not explosive athletes)
- Awkward touch (neither are particularly creative at finishing)
- Limited footwork
- Inconsistent jumpshots
- Dissonant defensive effort.

The only real notable difference is Banchero has a far greater feel for the game, which is only going to lead him to being a more impactful player. Again, that's why he's the
good.

The David Lee comparison doesn't make sense because he wasn't a power player. He didn't overwhelm his opponent by trying to physically dominate them, hunting for the mismatch at every opportunity. That's where Julius and Banchero are eerily similar; they force themselves down on the block and bully their matchup to get to the rim, and their respective perimeter games are only complementary to that.
Notice how folks have this mental image of Julius being a 25/11/5 player, and what I'm shedding light on is that being the Bad, because that player is not conducive to winning basketball, whereas Paolo, who as I've already listed has similar measurables and style of play, is the Good.

It's not a comparison of their timelines of progression, it's a comparison to get folks to see what is impactful and what isn't of two models that are one and the same.
 

cartierhoe

Veteran
Joined
Jul 7, 2015
Messages
24,207
Reputation
8,316
Daps
115,281
Reppin
South Florida
I still can't believe these so called experts had Jabari Smith and Chet Holmgren ahead of Paolo Banchero.
:mjlol:
Yeah I had him as the most polished coming out of Duke, even if he didn't go number 1. Not saying Jabari and Chet won't be nice but he's come into the league ready as ever. Magic got one, they have a bright future.
 

Th3G3ntleman

Superstar
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
14,591
Reputation
-2,777
Daps
53,471
Reppin
NULL
His iso moveset is a work in progress but the fact he is getting to the line at the rate he is means that he is still retaining some efficiency even as he goes through rookie pains. This is literally going to be his worst year in the next 10-15 and he this good.
 

who_better_than_me

Time to go!!
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
26,374
Reputation
1,137
Daps
39,884
Reppin
NULL
Everybody eating off this draft. Bachero looking Melo. Jabari looking like a perennial DPOY candidate. Murray lookin solid Sactown. Chet might be apart of the new twin tower next season. Was a good draft for the tanks
 
Top