Is John Wall > Derrick Rose?

[FAH1223]

At their peaks you can't really take neither over the other.

Rose at his peak is an absolutely unstoppable scorer that just has jaw-dropping moves, one of the best scoring point guards of all time, and he can manage the game well.

Wall is a better point guard, he has great court vision and distributes the ball better than pretty much any point guard in the league. He's a better plug in and play player for any team needing a point guard, but he's not the scorer Rose is. As far as taking games over he just doesn't do it like Rose did, not to say Wall isn't capable though.

Defense is negligible in this conversation as I always say in conversations about point guards, though Wall is big enough to guard 2's, he generally doesn't. Rose has never been a liability on defense and that's all that really matters when it comes to point guard defense.

I agree, that's my analysis

 

[FAH1223]

GTFOH
ROSE AT HIS PEAK WAS MVP...
​

WILL WALL EVER BE A TOP 10 PLAYER IN THE NBA,​

LET ALONE MVP CALIBER?​

​

nikka ISNT EVEN HEAD AND SHOULDERS ​

ABOVE INJURED ROSE.



​

Wall has all the tools.

 

[CarltonJunior]

GTFOH
ROSE AT HIS PEAK WAS MVP...

WILL WALL EVER BE A TOP 10 PLAYER IN THE NBA,
LET ALONE MVP CALIBER?

nikka ISNT EVEN HEAD AND SHOULDERS
ABOVE INJURED ROSE.



​

Who knows? I'm really just saying that Wall is THE prototypical point guard.

Rose at his peak is one of the greatest scorers I've ever witnessed, and his impact on games with that scoring can't be matched by Wall. I'm being a little modest here though trying not to be a Rose stan.

 

[Tunez]

I'm going with Wall

 

[Brozay]

this thread is some shyt, @FAH1223 youre better than this

 

[Black]

Yes

 

[OG Talk]

Wall is better now. Not better than a healthy Rose from a few years back.

I'm still disappointed in Wall's scoring abilities. I thought he'd average 22/10 once he found his footing in the league.

Why does he need to score more when he's surrounded by capable shooters (6th in the entire league in FG%) and they have the 2nd best record in the conference?

 

[Sterling Archer]

I'm being a little modest here though trying not to be a Rose stan.

I appreciate your candor and effort but youre not doing a good job of it lol.

 

[Rekkapryde]

I would literally slap the shyt out of you if you were standing next to me

 

[Made Myself A Boss]

Wrong thread

 

[Eternal Tecate]

bookmarked

 

[GetSomeMoney]

Id take this year's Wall over a prime Rose

 

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

Hopefully Rose finds his game in time for the playoffs and that we get to see these two go at each other.

 

[GoldenGlove]

Id take this year's Wall over a prime Rose

What?

 

[GoldenGlove]

WILL WALL EVER BE A TOP 10 PLAYER IN THE NBA,
LET ALONE MVP CALIBER?




​

I think the answer to both of these questions is yes to be honest with you.