Is John Wall > Derrick Rose?
- Thread starter FAH1223
- Start date
Eddie Jordan
Pro
Wall. Better defender and passer.
beeez90
Pro
Why are we comparing an injured Derrick Rose vs a healthy John Wall? This is the dumbest comparison.
How about putting Stephen Curry, Derrick Rose (healthy) >>>>>> John, Wall, Chris Paul, Russell Westbrook
How about putting Stephen Curry, Derrick Rose (healthy) >>>>>> John, Wall, Chris Paul, Russell Westbrook
beeez90
Pro
I need to see receipts (a link from a credible source) for this.
what is a healthy Rose though?
I mean Wall is getting better and better... his biggest weakness is shot selection and that's a coaching gaffe that has Wittman telling Wall to take 20 foot two pointers just cause he's open.
I'm talking 2009/2010/2011 Rose when i say Healthy. Perhaps we will never see that Rose again but still just saying when Rose was balling he was better than Wall is right now
John Wall has improved with each year in this league
I feel like an a$$hole cause I really didnt think he was that good.
shut me the fukk up
I feel like an a$$hole cause I really didnt think he was that good.
shut me the fukk up
Gil Scott-Heroin
āšæ
NOT ONLY IS ROSE PLAYING HURT...
HES ONLY PLAYING 26 MINUTES A GAME.
WALL SHOULD HAVE BETTER NUMBERS ACROSS THE BOARD.
WHAT KIND OF fukk shyt IS THIS?
When is Rose not going to play hurt?
would much rather have john wall then whatever rose will become..
stepbackj34spud
Top 75 All-Time
John Wall is type trash 
At their peaks you can't really take neither over the other.
Rose at his peak is an absolutely unstoppable scorer that just has jaw-dropping moves, one of the best scoring point guards of all time, and he can manage the game well.
Wall is a better point guard, he has great court vision and distributes the ball better than pretty much any point guard in the league. He's a better plug in and play player for any team needing a point guard, but he's not the scorer Rose is. As far as taking games over he just doesn't do it like Rose did, not to say Wall isn't capable though.
Defense is negligible in this conversation as I always say in conversations about point guards, though Wall is big enough to guard 2's, he generally doesn't. Rose has never been a liability on defense and that's all that really matters when it comes to point guard defense.
Rose at his peak is an absolutely unstoppable scorer that just has jaw-dropping moves, one of the best scoring point guards of all time, and he can manage the game well.
Wall is a better point guard, he has great court vision and distributes the ball better than pretty much any point guard in the league. He's a better plug in and play player for any team needing a point guard, but he's not the scorer Rose is. As far as taking games over he just doesn't do it like Rose did, not to say Wall isn't capable though.
Defense is negligible in this conversation as I always say in conversations about point guards, though Wall is big enough to guard 2's, he generally doesn't. Rose has never been a liability on defense and that's all that really matters when it comes to point guard defense.
Rose may never be the player he was before the injuries.
John Wall will also never be the player Rose was before his injuries.
But at this moment, yes, John Wall is better than a diminished Rose. Not sure this needed a thread.
John Wall will also never be the player Rose was before his injuries.
But at this moment, yes, John Wall is better than a diminished Rose. Not sure this needed a thread.
