Is it possible for Pacquiao to catch Floyd all-time?

Can Manny catch Floyd?

  • Yes

  • Nah

  • He's already ahead :sas2:


Results are only viewable after voting.

seemorecizzy

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,399
Reputation
2,351
Daps
52,997
Reppin
NULL
Manny was a flyweight too which makes his accomplishments even crazier. Floyd couldn’t do that. He wouldn’t even fight Keith Thurman or Errol Spence. Yet Manny has to beat them at 40 years old to be ranked ahead?

While Floyd just chills and fights UFC fighters and Kpop kickboxers?

Marques and Morales beat Manny waayyyy better than Floyd did. Would you rank them ahead of Manny also?
Theres nothing manny can do to pass floyd
Floyd is just a better boxer than him
I dont no why its so hard for you to understand that
Marquez and morales beating manny doesnt help your point at all lmao

Mannys only fighting now cause hes broke
Floyd gave da sport 20 years
Your just mad he didnt lose
 

TDUBB

All Star
Joined
Nov 1, 2013
Messages
2,436
Reputation
-55
Daps
5,565
Theres nothing manny can do to pass floyd
Floyd is just a better boxer than him
I dont no why its so hard for you to understand that
Marquez and morales beating manny doesnt help your point at all lmao

Mannys only fighting now cause hes broke
Floyd gave da sport 20 years
Your just mad he didnt lose

Wake me up when Floyd actually beats someone in the prime.

I know the you Floyd fans are very insecure about your hero since you know... he hasn’t done shyt that’s close what Manny has accomplished.

Cant wait for that Floyd vs Mcgregor rematch. :mjlol:
 

seemorecizzy

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,399
Reputation
2,351
Daps
52,997
Reppin
NULL
Wake me up when Floyd actually beats someone in the prime.

I know the you Floyd fans are very insecure about your hero since you know... he hasn’t done shyt that’s close what Manny has accomplished.

Cant wait for that Floyd vs Mcgregor rematch. :mjlol:
Theres nothing to be concerned about lol
Manny and floyd fought, manny lost 10-2
Floyd had a tougher time wit emmanuel augustus lol
Its just the reality of the situation
Not sure why floyd manny discussions are still even in your head
shyt was over after the fight
 

THE MACHINE

night owl
Joined
May 27, 2012
Messages
26,877
Reputation
6,520
Daps
104,343
Reppin
P.G. County
lmfao @ this thread. while I appreciate what manuel does, he's not undefeated....and he lost to Mayweather :comeon:
Mayweather commands more cast in PPVs too. its not possible for pacman to catch him.
Undefeated isn't the end all be all but I agree the loss to Mayweather was a huge plus for Mayweather, and I actually think Mayweather beats him more convincingly 5 years earlier. And while Mayweather may not have fought a lot of fighters in their prime, his opponents were often 2 divisions heavier on fight night. My thing is the resume has to come into play at some point. I still have Manny behind Floyd but to me it's too close to say Manny can't ever catch him. Beating Spence (at 40+ y/o) would be the most impressive win out of both resumes.

Pac has:
Barrera
Thurman
Bradley
Margarito
Morales
Broner -say whatever we want but he's a 4 division champ and 10 years younger than Manny
Matthysse

Floyd has:
Corrales
Zab
Manny
Canelo
Maidana
Castillo

vs same opponents:
ODH (Floyd fought at 154)
Cotto (Floyd fought at 154)
JMM
Mosley
Hatton

Floyd (5-0) Manny (6-1-1)

Not gonna front, Floyd might be a bit farther ahead than i gave him credit for :pachaha: Manny might need a W against Spence and Bud to catch Floyd.
 

seemorecizzy

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,399
Reputation
2,351
Daps
52,997
Reppin
NULL
So all the fighters Manny lost to are better than him? :jbhmm:

You gotta stack head to head, resumes, who fought who in their primes, record vs same fighters and the outcomes. It's a lot more to it than Floyd beat Manny. And for the record, i have Floyd slightly ahead of Pacquiao, but if Pacquiao beat Spence i would but him ahead of Floyd.
Your making it more complicated than it has to be
Do you think manny pacquaio is better den tommy hearns?
 

Skip b

#SwiftSet
Joined
May 5, 2012
Messages
19,400
Reputation
-40
Daps
20,984
Reppin
Swiftset
Do you believe pacquaio is on the same boxing tier level as floyd mayweather and sugar ray yes or no? Cause it seems like your arguing just to argue breh:russ:

Regardless of if you disagree with my points ( i had marquez winning all 4 fights:yeshrug:) im pretty sure we arrived at the same conclusion that pacquaio is not a top 5 or top 10 fighter of all time.

And ali may have lost to norton, but he did not get knocked into a different dimension against
Norton:russ:.

Plus ali's prime was before he got banned:ehh:
As a Manny fan.......Who turned into a Manny hater because of his idotic fanbase at one point in time.......I never felt Manny lost to JMM fight one or two; how the fukk can you lose 24 rounds and you put the man on his ass 4 times to zero if we talking street rules no 10/8 or judges..... given so both 3-4 was unnecessary when it was visibly clear JMM was taking 80s wwe level of juice in both matches



JMM was a hof before the roids and the frivolous Manny win,......Ken Norton was a 3rd tier heavy in his time and a afterthought:stopitslime:
 

seemorecizzy

Superstar
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
16,399
Reputation
2,351
Daps
52,997
Reppin
NULL
As a Manny fan.......Who turned into a Manny hater because of his idotic fanbase at one point in time.......I never felt Manny lost to JMM fight one or two; how the fukk can you lose 24 rounds and you put the man on his ass 4 times to zero if we talking street rules no 10/8 or judges..... given so both 3-4 was unnecessary when it was visibly clear JMM was taking 80s wwe level of juice in both matches



JMM was a hof before the roids and the frivolous Manny win,......Ken Norton was a 3rd tier heavy in his time and a afterthought:stopitslime:
Regardless if they pacquaio won or not,
Ita debatable.
All 3 of their fights before :deadmanny: were debatable depending on how you judge fights
 

NormanConnors

Detroit/MSU Spartan Life
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
29,746
Reputation
5,434
Daps
61,041
Reppin
Detroit
Undefeated isn't the end all be all but I agree the loss to Mayweather was a huge plus for Mayweather, and I actually think Mayweather beats him more convincingly 5 years earlier. And while Mayweather may not have fought a lot of fighters in their prime, his opponents were often 2 divisions heavier on fight night. My thing is the resume has to come into play at some point. I still have Manny behind Floyd but to me it's too close to say Manny can't ever catch him. Beating Spence (at 40+ y/o) would be the most impressive win out of both resumes.

Pac has:
Barrera
Thurman
Bradley
Margarito
Morales
Broner -say whatever we want but he's a 4 division champ and 10 years younger than Manny
Matthysse

Floyd has:
Corrales
Zab
Manny
Canelo
Maidana
Castillo

vs same opponents:
ODH (Floyd fought at 154)
Cotto (Floyd fought at 154)
JMM
Mosley
Hatton

Floyd (5-0) Manny (6-1-1)

Not gonna front, Floyd might be a bit farther ahead than i gave him credit for :pachaha: Manny might need a W against Spence and Bud to catch Floyd.

As far as those resumes you posted

Floyd's >>>>>

How is this even a question :mjlol:. Manny has no chance


Cats are really forgetting how dangerous a prime Diego Corrales was, and Canelo on top of that, a prime Castillo, Hatton and Maidana too:dead:

The huge amount of weight cats are adding to Manny's greatness only helps Floyd's resume also because he is a listed victim on it too:heh:.

Even with cats like Mosley, casuals and some experts were picking Shane to win or had some type of doubt in regards to a Floyd victory. ODLH tons of experts and casuals alike were picking him to win so the washed argument cant be used there.

If Shane was washed pre fight then what does that make the version of Margarito that fought Manny? As Shane destroyed him (and Shane beat the rest of the career out of Tony like Floyd himself eventually did to Shane).

Manny has too many suspect performances career wise to bypass Floyd aside from resume.
 
Top