Is A Death Wish Remake A Good Idea?

MartyMcFly

What's up doc, can we rock?
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
59,888
Reputation
9,180
Daps
161,012
Reppin
P.G. County
So they've been talking about doing this for a minute and as of now, Bruce Willie is attached to star and Eli Roth just signed on to direct. I don't ask the question because I'm against remakes or think that Death Wish is some holy grail of film, but more so from the contextual aspect.

When Death Wish dropped, the crime rate was sky high, urban cities like New York were basically hell on earth, and the idea of a vigilante taking the law in his own hands was seen as wish-fulfillment for people who felt like the laws and the systems let them down. Cobra did the same thing for the 80s. To say nothing of the fact that Death Wish became a movie filled with race-bating and stereotypes and damn near said that a white man with a gun will save you because us black and brown people don't know how to act.

But the idea of vigilante justice today, especially when we've got situations like Orlando and Newtown, etc, is a tricky dance to do. Paul Kersey was portrayed as a hero and the country had a more simplified view of that type of shyt then. Now, I'm not so sure we can glorify a vigilante when the topic of guns has become such an issue and cops taking the law in their own hands and popping kids for holding toy guns. I'm sure there's a great way to make a new death wish movie by applying more nuance to it and making it a thoughtful piece of filmmaking and a character study, which is what the original tried to be and some people say accomplished although I disagree. With that said, Eli Roth is directing and I'm not sure if he's the most thoughtful cat to do that, but I could be wrong.

So what does the film room think?

Death Wish Remake Hires Eli Roth to Direct
 

Poetical Poltergeist

Precise and cold hearted
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
36,349
Reputation
5,316
Daps
117,250
Reppin
Mile in the Sky
It's written by the cats who wrote Ed wood and the OJ mini so there's something there possibly but from a social context is it a good look?
With Roth at the helm idk..Bruce been bland for a long time now I don't see this being taken serious.

If it tries to be serious toned, it could backfire. Have to get better actor and director on board to make a social statement. That could backfire too if there's blatant pandering. Just make a gritty thriller is my advice.
 

MartyMcFly

What's up doc, can we rock?
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
59,888
Reputation
9,180
Daps
161,012
Reppin
P.G. County
With Roth at the helm idk..Bruce been bland for a long time now I don't see this being taken serious.

If it tries to be serious toned, it could backfire. Have to get better actor and director on board to make a social statement. That could backfire too if there's blatant pandering. Just make a gritty thriller is my advice.

That's what I'm saying tho lol..Death Wish is or at least was a social statement. Making it a gritty thriller in the same vein as the original is going to backfire tremendously, in my eyes. And I don't see Eli or Bruce being keen enough to pull it off and examine the subject through 2016 or 2017 eyes rather than the eyes of the 70s.
 

StraxStrax

I'm selling these fine leather jackets
Joined
Jul 5, 2012
Messages
8,762
Reputation
880
Daps
16,636
They should remake bad movies so Death Wish is very high on the remake list.
 

the next guy

Superstar
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
37,933
Reputation
1,446
Daps
36,344
Reppin
NULL
So they've been talking about doing this for a minute and as of now, Bruce Willie is attached to star and Eli Roth just signed on to direct. I don't ask the question because I'm against remakes or think that Death Wish is some holy grail of film, but more so from the contextual aspect.

When Death Wish dropped, the crime rate was sky high, urban cities like New York were basically hell on earth, and the idea of a vigilante taking the law in his own hands was seen as wish-fulfillment for people who felt like the laws and the systems let them down. Cobra did the same thing for the 80s. To say nothing of the fact that Death Wish became a movie filled with race-bating and stereotypes and damn near said that a white man with a gun will save you because us black and brown people don't know how to act.

But the idea of vigilante justice today, especially when we've got situations like Orlando and Newtown, etc, is a tricky dance to do. Paul Kersey was portrayed as a hero and the country had a more simplified view of that type of shyt then. Now, I'm not so sure we can glorify a vigilante when the topic of guns has become such an issue and cops taking the law in their own hands and popping kids for holding toy guns. I'm sure there's a great way to make a new death wish movie by applying more nuance to it and making it a thoughtful piece of filmmaking and a character study, which is what the original tried to be and some people say accomplished although I disagree. With that said, Eli Roth is directing and I'm not sure if he's the most thoughtful cat to do that, but I could be wrong.

So what does the film room think?

Death Wish Remake Hires Eli Roth to Direct
I was going to say no but Bruce Willis...
 
Top