If You Could Live Without Oxygen, Could You Talk

[Mr. Somebody]

I just thought of something friends. Anyone who could live withoutt he use of oxygen would have to use telepathy to talk. It seems that breathing is a primary component of language and without air, you cannot speak. Wow, friends.

 

[VerbalIntercourse]

I just thought of something friends. Anyone who could live withoutt he use of oxygen would have to use telepathy to talk. It seems that breathing is a primary component of language and without air, you cannot speak. Wow, friends.

This is simply a misguided statement. You need to work through this logically and then re-evaluate your conclusion.

 

[Mr. Somebody]

This is simply a misguided statement. You need to work through this logically and then re-evaluate your conclusion.

Hold your breath and speak then put your hands to your mouth. How can you use words without air escaping your lungs.

 

[88m3]

You're essentially questioning god fakkit

 

[Mr. Somebody]

You're essentially questioning god fakkit

Im trying to imagine the unimaginable. God gave you breath to speak his word, without the air that god has breathed into your body you cannot say a word. There is no life without oxygen and therefore there are no words unless they are in your mind.

Edit. Please dont use profanity. Its tacky, and makes you look cheap and obviously, demonic, friend.

 

[Egomaniacal1]

Everything originates from the mind.




Oh and sign language ftw.

 

[Mr. Somebody]

Everything originates from the mind.




Oh and sign language ftw.

Ahh yes, sign language. This would definately work but at least we agree that there are no words without oxygen. Also, how can you create words in your mind without a sound to reference them to. How can you create sound from your mouth without air. I believe you have to click your tongue? What is a tongue without oxygen?

 

[daze23]

sound also needs the air to travel. without air I couldn't hear the Nas album right now

 

[Mr. Somebody]

sound also needs the air to travel. without air I couldn't hear the Nas album right now

There is sound in outer space though. Do we hear it from waves that hit the earth or from sattelites that are already in space?

 

[Egomaniacal1]

I agree that without oxygen we could not speak words as we know them. Sound needs some sort of medium to travel. Words are just a means of communication and if no one had that means to communicate by we'd just fall back to another method, ie everyone would learn sign language.

 

[daze23]

There is sound in outer space though. Do we hear it from waves that hit the earth or from sattelites that are already in space?

they communicate with radio and microwaves, not sound

no matter what, life is good

 

[L&HH]

sound also needs the air to travel. without air I couldn't hear the Nas album right now

The op said no oxygen though. No Oxygen does not = No Air. Ok correction he does say "without air..." but I think he too was mistaken about what he said. So is it no oxygen or is it no air?

 

[Crakface]

The op said no oxygen though. No Oxygen does not = No Air. Ok correction he does say "without air..." but I think he too was mistaken about what he said. So is it no oxygen or is it no air?

He seems a little slow he probably meant air.

 

[Dusty Bake Activate]

He seems a little slow he probably meant air.

You correcting yourself under different aliases now?

 

[L&HH]

You correcting yourself under different aliases now?

tf is going on?