if Eminem in your top5 DOA then your hip hop pass should be revoked ASAP

Saint1

Superstar
Joined
May 3, 2012
Messages
8,408
Reputation
915
Daps
24,324
Reppin
CA
Em is an amazing rapper. He had the hype like no one I've seen (obviously a large part was him being white).

BUT

His songs never meant anything to me. Fantasizing about killing his wife and torturing his mom. Being hated and being a menace to conservative parents (on his first album though :jbhmm:?) Waging war with pop stars.

I have these lines running through my mind every other day or two and they mean something that applies to life.


Nas - If I ruled the world I'd free all my sons
BIG - Birthdays was the worst days / now we sip champagne when we thirsty
Jay - Blindfolded, expected to walk a straight line / Mind molded, taught to love you and hate mine
Pac - Dear Mama, Tryin to make a dollar out of 15 cents, Keep your head up, etc, etc
Scarface - Can't talk to my mother so I talk to my diary
Andre 3000 - She said, "Why you in the club, and you don't make it precipitate?
You know, make it rain when you can make it thunderstorm"
I'm like, "Why? "
The world needs sun
The hood needs funds​
Wu-Tang - CREAM
Snoop - Rollin down the street, smokin indo, sippin on gin and juice
NWA - fukk tha Police
Dre - Nuthin But a G Thang
DJ Quik - If it don't make dollarz it dont make sense


:manny: I ain't hatin' on Em but dude is severely overrated. And if you ask me would I PERSONALLY put those artists above Em? Yeah, I would because to this day I'll still play those classics. I ain't listened to an Eminem album in years and none of his off the wall lyrics pop in my head.
 

The Ruler 09

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
37,956
Reputation
1,687
Daps
38,027
Reppin
NULL
He's nowhere near a legitimate top 5, or 20 to me. At his best he can rap but but horrible music for the most part and childish subjects with low rent shock value. When you diss current pop stars for example that's very in the moment and that shyt sounds awful now, a lot of his shyt does, Encore still has some of the worst music I've ever heard, songs like Fack and a lot more were extremely embarrassing and disgraceful. You compare for example to 2 Pac, or Nas or a bunch of people who have been so much more diverse, Pac had Blasphemy, Keep Ya Head Up, I Get Around, Thugs Passion, Dear Mama, so many others, songs that Eminem is incapable of making, Pac was just on another level. Could say that about many artists, Eminem's lane was too limited, it lacks soul for the most part, it lacks substance, value, knowledge, love, positivity, so much, to each to their own but he's lacking a lot to be in that elite category to me. There's been a lot of great rappers of Hip Hop's history.
 

1-8-7-Skillz

Superstar
Joined
Sep 24, 2015
Messages
6,515
Reputation
1,590
Daps
16,607
He can rap thats for sure, but his catalog is horrible. He doesn't have an even remotly classic album, his voice is horrible, subject matter is also awful for the most part. Can't understand how so many people can still praise the hell out of this gimmicky shock value crap he does, just sounds embarassing as fukk.
 

LEEeveryday

The-Coli Music Critic
Supporter
Joined
Sep 4, 2015
Messages
8,082
Reputation
4,066
Daps
30,451
Reppin
#LyricsMatter
I feel like Eminem being in the top 5 has been forced on us. His music doesn't justify the ranking. Sure he has talent, but whats the point if he doesn't make good music?

His first 2 albums are personal favorites, but then he kinda didn't make shyt I liked after that...
 

th_412

I fux deez hoes
Joined
Apr 11, 2014
Messages
1,162
Reputation
600
Daps
8,950
Reppin
Yo bytch bedroom / PITTSBURGH
Didn't This king Karim dude come on here pretending to be cool with Suge and ppl from Death row and was posting a buncha pics only to find out he was pump fakin and stole the pics from another forum and claimed them as his? :patrice:
 

DaveyDave

Superstar
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
16,247
Reputation
2,253
Daps
29,271
Reppin
Australia
straight up spittin you would have to put him somewhere in the top 10 but when you're talking about the whole thing together he couldn't be anywhere inside the top 20 IMO i would prob have him listen way under that
 
Top