Why would that be superior to a credit modeling system? You think it should be "relationship" based? How would that work? You don't think their should be objective terms for loans?
Key word there is APPROVED.
So based on your relationship with the bank/credit union (paying your debts to them on time, paying debts earlier than the term limit) and your income (making enough money to pay your debts back) they approach loan approvals based on those factors.
There would still be loan terms but getting approved or rejected wouldn’t be purely based on a number most people don’t understand.
Someone could have an 740 score but their credit profile is thin but get approved for everything. The other person could have a 670, big profile but never paid anything late and still get denied just because of their score.
The person with the 740 is going to be deemed “more worthy” than the person with the 670 even though the 670 has a strong track record of paying debts on time. That’s my beef with credit scores. It’s too focused on the number