2k5 was great but it's been surpassed
the only thing 2k5 still does better than Madden is the presentation.
In what way??????
I have been playing 2k5 a lot lately on my gamertag and the game is amazing.
I am seeing Neutral Zone Infractions, Clipping, Pass Inference, Real Holding Penalties and the challenge system is better than Madden has ever been. Crazy the game is 7 years old and still shyts on the newer games. Momentum was so realistic in this game its crazy.
Had Ray Lewis blow the O-line up on a blitz to get to a running back in the backfield on a third down play. The game was amazing.