"HOW CAN YOU LAUGH!!" Mindy Kaling, other South Asian comedians called out for perpetuating stereotypes

[Doobie Doo]

Mindy Kaling, other South Asian comedians called out for perpetuating stereotypes​

"But if you want to make fun of South Asians, where do those insults usually come from? South Asian comedians"

Chandler Treon
December 12, 2022



South Asian TikTok users are pushing back against harmful stereotypes, with one creator attributing their popularity to South Asian comedians.

In a video posted last month that has garnered over 332,000 views and 60,000 likes, TikTok user Jasmine (@totallyprincessjasmine) criticizes a clip from the HBO Max series “The Sex Lives of College Girls,” which was created and produced by Mindy Kaling. In the clip, Bela, played by Amrit Kaur, talks to her parents about how she used to be an “Indian loser.”

“Mindy Kaling. Just because you are an Indian loser, does not mean Indians are losers,” Jasmine says in their video. “At this point you’re genuinely doing more harm than good.”



Stitching Jasmine’s video, TikTok user Aqil Dhanani (@aqildhanani) goes on to claim that South Asian comedians are to blame for the promotion of harmful stereotypes in the U.S.

Dhanani calls out Kaling and stand-up comedians Russell Peters and Lily Singh in particular:

“If you’re in America and you want to be racist against Black people, you can deep dive into the ancient tomes of racism and find a stereotype or a slur. Same with East Asians, same with Latinos. But if you want to make fun of South Asians, where do those insults usually come from? South Asian comedians,” he says. “Mindy Kaling, Russell Peters, Lilly Singh, what do they talk about? Our parents talk funny and they beat us and we eat stinky food and we are stinky and there’s hair all over.”

Singh faced backlash in 2019 for comparing turbans to towels on her late-night show. Peters, who was the first comedian to have a Netflix stand-up special, is known for his imitations of Indian stereotypes, with his most famous bit being about his father’s penchant for corporal punishment, which ends with his signature catchphrase: “Somebody gonna get a hurt real bad.”



Dhanani says the popularity of comedians who promoted harmful South Asian stereotypes affected the way he was treated in high school.

He points out that audiences feel comfortable repeating these stereotypes “because a Brown person said it on TV.”

“Russell Peters popped off when I was in high school, and I had white people coming up to me in the hallway and quoting Russell Peters and laughing about it,” he explains.

“And I just played along! I laughed along, I added on, because that’s how you fit in with white people. You let them laugh at you.”

Dhanani then shows a news article from his time working as tech support for his city in which he is described as a “Tech Guru.” The screenshot of the article even describes his workstation as “a table with a ‘Tech Guru’ sign in the adult section of the library.”

The TikTok creator also calls out the popularity and use of “the voice,” referring to an exaggerated Indian accent, by stand-up comedians.

Dhanani explains that a cousin of his who is a professional stand-up comedian on TikTok uses “the voice” in “every single one of her videos.”

“In her stand-up routines, just like Lilly Singh, she does the voice to make fun of her parents. And just like Lilly Singh, her parents don’t have that accent.”

Mindy Kaling, other South Asian comedians called out for perpetuating stereotypes

"But if you want to make fun of South Asians, where do those insults usually come from? South Asian comedians"

nextshark.com

 

[Json]

The white people Indians want to be apart of find it funny. That’s why they do it.

 

[Clark Wayne]

This quote

“Mindy Kaling. Just because you are an Indian loser, does not mean Indians are losers,” Jasmine says in their video. “At this point you’re genuinely doing more harm than good.”

 

[Scustin Bieburr]

Asians gotta keep calling out their c00ns. They BEEN tap dancing for white acceptance.

 

[Sonic Boom of the South]

“If you’re in America and you want to be racist against Black people, you can deep dive into the ancient tomes of racism and find a stereotype or a slur. Same with East Asians, same with Latinos. But if you want to make fun of South Asians, where do those insults usually come from? South Asian comedians,” he says. “Mindy Kaling, Russell Peters, Lilly Singh, what do they talk about? Our parents talk funny and they beat us and we eat stinky food and we are stinky and there’s hair all over.”




wtf is this supposed to mean?


If you are in America and want to be racist against Black People.....


Is this shyt trying to say no one outside of South Asian comedians have stereotypes that they list about South Asians?

 

[levitate]

she loves her some white men.

 

[MajesticLion]

 

[2stainz]

@Napolean

 

[Scustin Bieburr]

“If you’re in America and you want to be racist against Black people, you can deep dive into the ancient tomes of racism and find a stereotype or a slur. Same with East Asians, same with Latinos. But if you want to make fun of South Asians, where do those insults usually come from? South Asian comedians,” he says. “Mindy Kaling, Russell Peters, Lilly Singh, what do they talk about? Our parents talk funny and they beat us and we eat stinky food and we are stinky and there’s hair all over.”









 wtf is this supposed to mean?





if you are in America and want to be racist against Black People.....





is this shyt trying to say no one outside of South Asians comedians has stereotypes that they list about South Asians?

She's saying that they're the biggest c00ns. They're actively talking about the stereotypes at length in all their their work thereby working to keep the stereotypes alive.

 

[Black Hans]

“If you’re in America and you want to be racist against Black people, you can deep dive into the ancient tomes of racism and find a stereotype or a slur. Same with East Asians, same with Latinos. But if you want to make fun of South Asians, where do those insults usually come from? South Asian comedians,” he says. “Mindy Kaling, Russell Peters, Lilly Singh, what do they talk about? Our parents talk funny and they beat us and we eat stinky food and we are stinky and there’s hair all over.”




wtf is this supposed to mean?


if you are in America and want to be racist against Black People.....


is this shyt trying to say no one outside of South Asians comedians has stereotypes that they list about South Asians?

It means that racial slurs and stereotypes toward black people generally start with non-black people, while stereotypes about South Asians usually start with South Asians themselves.

 

[KidJSoul]

Mindy Kaling always made it obvious she wished she was white. Literally look at every show she's made.

I haven't listened to much of Ruseel Peters but I'm not surprised

 

[Rarely-Wrong Liggins]

This is the type of talk that got Apu canceled. The fact of the matter is that these stereotypes do exist and they usually aren't portrayed as harmful. Apu was probably one of the better morally centered characters on the Simpsons. His biggest "flaw" was having an accent. Are they going to get rid of that redneck character, Cletus too?

Do these south Asian comedians spread stereotypes about a lot of the males being involved in mass rapes, killing of rape victims, entire countries participating in the scam economy or the totally unsanitary conditions they find themselves in?

Indians for example are often portrayed as awkward but overall successful nerds. The harmful stereotype argument would be a lot more valid if there was segments where these south east Asians were riffing about the "plese send bobs" segment of their society.

 

[AAKing23]

she loves her some white men.

Extremely, everything that bytch writes has an Asian/Indian chick getting saved by Brad

 

[Sonic Boom of the South]

She's saying that they're the biggest c00ns. They're actively talking about the stereotypes at length in all their their work thereby working to keep the stereotypes alive.

Comes off like it is saying
No one sees anything negative about South Asians
And the only negative that exist is by South Asian comedians
As if the person saying it think no one shyts on them

 

[Theolodius_Black]

she loves her some white men.

Shorty even said when they made the jokes at get school she'd laugh, because "that's what you do to fit in with white people". So my question is, by not standing up then, is this a pot/kettle situation or a better late than never situation?