Girls (HBO Show) Discussion thread

dennis roadman

nuclear war in my bag
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
20,451
Reputation
3,495
Daps
40,275
Reppin
solsbury hill
I didn't get that from that scene at all. I thought it was clearly Hannah's fault for just being alive. She fukks everything up just by being "there." For everyone. For everything. Hannah ruins everyone's life. In the real world, Hannah commits suicide because of this realization.

I thought that was clear as day with the way Adam always bounced back after their breakups.

In fact, its their friendships that are really ruining their lives. Every single person on this show should've grown out of this 7 friend group by now.
i dont see it. this was the beginning of hannah's redemption arc, whether it's ultimately fruitful or not. she didn't do anything wrong, and she wasn't there - she barely interacted with jessa after the wedding, and with adam all season

adam never bounced back from anything, he was in the hospital begging to get back with her and got rejected. both of them just got into rebound relationships. hannah's ended with her actually coming off like the sane one, and adam tore his whole apartment up

i hate hannah as much as the next person, but this was her time
 

Captain Crunch

Veteran
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
44,420
Reputation
2,449
Daps
112,493
Reppin
NY
i dont see it. this was the beginning of hannah's redemption arc, whether it's ultimately fruitful or not. she didn't do anything wrong, and she wasn't there - she barely interacted with jessa after the wedding, and with adam all season

adam never bounced back from anything, he was in the hospital begging to get back with her and got rejected. both of them just got into rebound relationships. hannah's ended with her actually coming off like the sane one, and adam tore his whole apartment up

i hate hannah as much as the next person, but this was her time

Adam has made a career out of acting once Hannah left for Iowa(the beginning of their breakup).
On a unrelated note, I love how this show has matured this season.
 

tru_m.a.c

IC veteran
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
31,274
Reputation
6,840
Daps
90,732
Reppin
Gaithersburg, MD via Queens/LI
i dont see it. this was the beginning of hannah's redemption arc, whether it's ultimately fruitful or not. she didn't do anything wrong, and she wasn't there - she barely interacted with jessa after the wedding, and with adam all season

adam never bounced back from anything, he was in the hospital begging to get back with her and got rejected. both of them just got into rebound relationships. hannah's ended with her actually coming off like the sane one, and adam tore his whole apartment up

i hate hannah as much as the next person, but this was her time
You're wildin. Jessa is Hannah best friend. Hannahs existence is what makes her and Adam doubt their relationship. Why do you think they're hiding it? Why do you think Marnie was hiding her shyt with Ray from Shoosh? You can't date your best friends ex b.

Secondly, everything about Adams life got better after he broke up with Hannah. Remember, Hannah went suicidal and started sticking shyt in her ear. Adam went out and got a beautiful girlfriend and started having normal relations. The moment he ran into Hannag, or rather Hannah ran into him and forced a conversation, he went and had angry sex with his girlfriend, nutted on her chest, then stopped talking to her.

He stopped drinking after Hannah.

His acting career took off the moment he distanced himself from Hannah.

Every angry Adam relapse takes place after a Hannah appearance.

Listen to Hannah and Frans breakup again. "I've never acted like this in my life." How many times have people said that after interacting with that bytch. Iowa sealed the deal on that bytch.
 

dennis roadman

nuclear war in my bag
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
20,451
Reputation
3,495
Daps
40,275
Reppin
solsbury hill
You're wildin. Jessa is Hannah best friend. Hannahs existence is what makes her and Adam doubt their relationship. Why do you think they're hiding it? Why do you think Marnie was hiding her shyt with Ray from Shoosh? You can't date your best friends ex b.

Secondly, everything about Adams life got better after he broke up with Hannah. Remember, Hannah went suicidal and started sticking shyt in her ear. Adam went out and got a beautiful girlfriend and started having normal relations. The moment he ran into Hannag, or rather Hannah ran into him and forced a conversation, he went and had angry sex with his girlfriend, nutted on her chest, then stopped talking to her.

He stopped drinking after Hannah.

His acting career took off the moment he distanced himself from Hannah.

Every angry Adam relapse takes place after a Hannah appearance.

Listen to Hannah and Frans breakup again. "I've never acted like this in my life." How many times have people said that after interacting with that bytch. Iowa sealed the deal on that bytch.
bro i'm not saying hannah doesn't fukk all sorts of shyt up. she's a mess, it is amazing she has any friends

all i'm saying is in this instance, adam and jessa, two addicts, got together and wreaked havoc on one another. it would have happened with or without hannah, who happened to be on a relative come-up at the same time, which is not a coincidence since this is all scripted, after all

if you watch lena dunham's little talks after the episodes, she's said a few times that fran is not really a nice guy, and that's why hannah resents him (hannah implied the same of course, but this is the writer herself saying it, meaning in the Girls-verse, it's fact). watching it as a man, i thought fran was acting pretty rationally given the situation, but watching it as someone who was aware of the writer's perspective, fran was supposed to look like the a$$hole here. that hannah handled it all kinda calmly was proof of that, because that's never really been her before

and right now im sitting here laughing because a bunch of grown men on a sports and hip hop forum are going on at length debating the meaning of this show :mjlol:
 

tru_m.a.c

IC veteran
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
31,274
Reputation
6,840
Daps
90,732
Reppin
Gaithersburg, MD via Queens/LI
bro i'm not saying hannah doesn't fukk all sorts of shyt up. she's a mess, it is amazing she has any friends

all i'm saying is in this instance, adam and jessa, two addicts, got together and wreaked havoc on one another. it would have happened with or without hannah, who happened to be on a relative come-up at the same time, which is not a coincidence since this is all scripted, after all

How would it have happened without Hannah if they started fighting because Jessa kept bringing up Hannah?

if you watch lena dunham's little talks after the episodes, she's said a few times that fran is not really a nice guy, and that's why hannah resents him (hannah implied the same of course, but this is the writer herself saying it, meaning in the Girls-verse, it's fact). watching it as a man, i thought fran was acting pretty rationally given the situation, but watching it as someone who was aware of the writer's perspective, fran was supposed to look like the a$$hole here. that hannah handled it all kinda calmly was proof of that, because that's never really been her before
:heh: of course she would say Fran was not a nice guy and never provide evidence of such. She said it repeatedly during the episode. It's a defensive mechanism. Dude, in the same episode, she tried to argue that she wasn't wrong and shouldnt be judged for showing her boss her p*ssy. She also gave a blowjob to the ex of a best friend, who she snitched on because he was fukkn another one of her best friends, during a time she was mad at her best friend - for sleeping with her ex. :laff:

You believe that person when they call someone judgemental?
 

beenz

Rap Guerilla
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
81,670
Reputation
10,021
Daps
184,237
Reppin
The Chi (South Side)
Nah, HYMIM was starting to ascend right when it got cancelled. Kappa; Ben's ex, and Luis Gusman>>>just about all of Girls' supporting characters.

and that's what made me the maddest about it's abrupt cancellation. I felt it was just hitting its stride. meanwhile girls has some straight :trash: ratings and is going on it's 6th season and what not.
 
Top