Those negative opinions you listed are from like a few years ago. For as goofy comedy as they are, they've also shown by now that they can get serious, they can go toe to toe with anyone and the ring, all 3 have become fantastic talkers, they routinely put on the funniest, most natural comedy promos that they clearly are helping to write themselves, they consistently put on great matches, they're amazing at PR, they're always coming up with new tweaks to keep it fresh, they were great heels and faces both, multiple reigns as both...just every box ticked.
I love that they take advantage of the Freebird rule whenever they want and all 3 can go. I dont know any wrestling fan that thinks Xavier cant wrestle in 2018. I'd say you'll find more people calling him underrated and a great in-ring storyteller. Big E and Kofi are each due a big singles push. Not sure how they do it while keeping the team together.
At this point they should be in any goat tag team / stable discussion.
theyre not a a stable until one of them puts in work as a single wrestler while reppin new day.
and it could be done. if the WWE knew what they were doing, they wouldn't have to break them up in order to give one of them a singles push.
and yea, the goofy comedy will always hold them back in the all-time talks.