Eminem - MMLP2 Discussion Thread

[Ranger21]

about as personal as it gets...em was prob heated when this leaked

 

[*crackSTAR*]

at rap god

 

[Harry B]

Pitchfork are just hating the same way they were hating on jay.

Ain't no way this is 4.7 or Jay's album 5.9
Which in pitchfork terms mean that both are 2 mics .

Album gets doper, the only problem I have is that most beats are meh.

 

[Wall]

don't front

 

[desp]

How did this guy manage to release an album full of garbage, then a handful of wack bonus tracks....

.... but then drop Don't Front?

This is the best Marshall track in ten years brehs

 

[H.J.Duck]

Pitchfork are just hating the same way they were hating on jay.

Ain't no way this is 4.7 or Jay's album 5.9
Which in pitchfork terms mean that both are 2 mics .

Album gets doper, the only problem I have is that most beats are meh.

Pitchfork's problem with those albums is (no matter what they write) is that listening to Jay-Z or Eminem in 2013 is not considered "cool" or trendy...and they dont have that 'fake artistic' vibe someone like Kanye has.

 

[ArchStanton]

That Paste review was filled with so many minor inaccuracies that it was hard to take serious. I'm a stickler for that kind of stuff. For example, he claims "Bad Guy" is following Stan again, and that the beat switch happens 7 minutes in. And he claims Rihanna sings the hook to "Legacy."

 

[Prae]

Em's vault must be crazy. Hopefully one day we get to hear it

Based on all those songs that leaked (most were crap imo), it seems like most songs would suck (unless there's stuff locked up from 97-03). Although I would be interested in hearing what was scrapped from Relapse 2.

And his whole forum is a Stan empire that even I'm like

Lol yea if you think the stans on this board are bad, they're 100x worse on there. People are rating that album as high as 8, 9, even 10/10. People on threre say it's flawless. That it has great production. I've even seen multiple people rate it above either sslp or tes

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

Pitchfork are just hating the same way they were hating on jay.

Ain't no way this is 4.7 or Jay's album 5.9
Which in pitchfork terms mean that both are 2 mics .

Album gets doper, the only problem I have is that most beats are meh.

I don't check for pitchfork but those are accurate reviews. Mediocre albums bro even u said the beats are meh.

 

[MartyMcFly]

Pitchfork's problem with those albums is (no matter what they write) is that listening to Jay-Z or Eminem in 2013 is not considered "cool" or trendy...and they dont have that 'fake artistic' vibe someone like Kanye has.

I feel like Yeezus is going to be looked at the way people look at The Shining..they say they don't like horror movies but they love The Shining. So for people who say they don't like hip hop or don't like "that rap music" they will say they love Yeezus. Em and Jay are better rappers than Kanye so for that alone, I don't get their ratings. I'm surprised they reviewed My Name is My Name as favorably as they did.

 

[Kill Dat Noize]

The more people talk about Pitchfork the more legitimacy they can claim so stop talkin about em. No one's opinion should hold that much weight.

The person who wrote that review is just an ordinary listener like you and me.

 

[WeInHere]

I think this is a really good album. Very diverse. Need a number of more listens to take it all in!

 

[MattP215]

anyone ever know what happened to this song?

 

[Izanami]

Album could have been great if there was some thought process in putting out the best album possible. Some type of brain work to keep the best songs and keep the album to a cohesive sound.

 

[HamAndEgger]

First Week Sales: 700-750K