Pull Up the Roots
Veteran
You would likely lose that bet. I'm not arguing for appeasement here, nor am I of the belief that we should throw trans people under the bus. I am only challenging this single assertion, using what I've been reading since the end of the election.So it's "resenting the rich" to acknowledge the wealthy often pay lower tax rates than many workers and the game is rigged against workers? Is it "resenting the rich" to acknowledge stuff like buy borrow die shouldn't be allowed to exist?
I bet Trump saying he was going to get rid of taxes on overtime pay had more on an impact than all that transgender stuff.
Immigration isn't about culture wars it's about the perceived economic threat of the government giving handouts to illegal immigrants and them taking potential jobs from citizens.
While it's true that [bad] economic policies like getting rid of taxes overtime pay could have a direct impact on a workers financial well-being, it's important to not underestimate the profound effect that cultural issues, particularly trans rights, can have on certain voters. For example, I was reading about how many Teamsters union members voted for Trump because they were convinced that their children's futures were at risk from what they perceived as a "radical agenda" pushed by the Dems wrt the normalization of trans identities. This was a deeply personal fear about their "cultural" and "social" values being under attack.
Those working-class voters felt that Dem support for trans rights and the push for inclusive policies in schools and workplaces were a threat to their "traditional values," especially around gender and sexuality. It was a fear that their children could be "turned" into something they perceived as unnatural or harmful. Even though there's no factual basis for this fear. Trans identity isn't something that can be "imposed" on children. Anyway, the emotional and cultural impact of those concerns is profound. These cultural wars matter because they tap into deep-seated fears about identity, family, and the future. And to them, that takes precedence over "economic" issues.
It's crucial not to dismiss or downplay them as distractions or lesser concerns compared to economic policy. For many of these voters, particularly in the working class, these cultural issues are seen as existential threats to their "values" and to their way of life. I think economic issues matter, and I support making that the core "identity" of the party, but we need to also be honest that it isn't about economic issues alone for large swathes of this country. Culture wars hold real power. They're not just emotional or social distractions, they shape how a lot of people view their place in society and the world they want to leave to their children.