To the people that are old enough to have seen this in real time:
How was the reaction to that dude and tha realest being pushed on those compilations etc ? I can’t imagine anyone actually taking this serious
As someone who was (and still is when leaks come out) a Death Row stan, even back then I thought pushing Tha Realest was a mistake. In the moment, it was evident that Tha Realest was trying to be like 2pac to the point that supposedly a few of his songs are rumored to be songs 2pac wrote but never recorded (i.e. "They Wanna Be Like Us" where that verse describes 2pac to a t). In hindsight it says a lot that outside of appearances in "Unconditional Love" and "Cindafella", they never spent the money to produce a video for any of his tracks.
At the time, IMO Top Dogg actually could have had some success had they not leaned into the Snoop comparisons. To me he never sounded identical to Snoop; I thought he sounded more like a cross between CPO and Too Short. DJ Quik actually gave him one of my favorite Quik beats of all time with "We don't love em" and he actually had some tight songs with "Goin' Back 2 Cali", "Me & My Boyz", "If you can't take the heat", and "Dope Money".
To me that Top Dogg/Tha Realest era ended with Too Gangsta 4 Radio. I think a lot of DR fans felt the same way that Crooked I blew everyone else out of the water and he should have been a fukking star much earlier in his career. That's probably the feedback Suge got which is why after that album, they bushed the both of them to try rebuilding the label (in summer 2001) around Crooked I, SKG, PB, J. Valentine, Eastwood and Above the Law.