Could Winter Soldier be the best superhero movie ever made?

[Kill Dat Noize]

I love both TWS and TDK, I prefer TDK to it, if you think the other way around, cool. To me it seems that you have more of a problem with the praise TDK gets, because in your opinion it is not justified.

well the praise for TDK is so great that you cannot even suggest another movie is better. look at this thread. look how many ppl won't even consider another movie in that spot.

I think it has way more to do with the hype and the Heath ledger performance than the actual quality of the film. yes it was an ambitious take on the genre but the overall execution just doesn't measure up imo. the characters sans joker are all stiff and boring, the plot is insanely bloated, the pacing is agonizing...it is a chore to sit through.

cap 2 has things going on beneath the surface too and is a smart action movie but it is also fun and enjoyable all the way through with much better characters and a much tighter plot.

 

[Spiritual Stratocaster]

The actor that plays Captain america is wack bruh.He aint even a man.All i see is a little kid dressed up when i see him on the screen.I can't get into none of his action scenes.I'm just so use to comic cap being so gangsta wit it i guess.

 

[Ninjaz In Paris]

Chris Evans is a great Cap to me he convinced me in Avengers 1

Evans was BORN to play Captain America... all that Fantastic 4, Push, The Losers & Scott Pilgrim were him just warming up for his true purpose...

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

no tension? What? With winter soldier? do you remember the car chase with hydra, Bucky and fury? There was no tension when the elevator was filling up every stop with cap chillin? You didn't see it at the theater did you

I saw it first day at the theater...like that would make a difference. But There's no tension in any of the marvel films. They all too safe. U never feel there's a threat, even furys death seemed fake and it was revealed as such. shyt is for kids.

 

[Jello Biafra]

Winter Soldier might be the best Marvel Studios movie but it isn't the best super-hero movie or even best movie based on a comic book character.

 

[Ribbs]

Best? No. But you can probably convince me that it's better. Dark Knight is just even to this day.

Someone mentioned X-Men 2, it's up there in the conversation, so is Spider-Man 2 but it kinda stops there. Everyone other superhero movie is fighting to get to that tier.

 

[Kings County]

the dark night >
bane>

 

[MooseMouthMthafuga]

"Old school" action/ story telling.

That "simplicity" made it somehow refreshing to me.

Had me feeling like a kid in the 90's again


It's way up there on the list.Dark Knight was some tough shyt.

Loved X2...Spiderman 2...even The Incredible Hulk

 

[Dominic Brehetto]

Its the 2nd best mcu film. Not even close to the best comic book film.

Its not even the best comic book film the year it came out.

 

[Czerka]

Marvel fags still butt hurt becaus theyll never get a movie as good as TDK

 

[Roman Brady]

I saw it first day at the theater...like that would make a difference. But There's no tension in any of the marvel films. They all too safe. U never feel there's a threat, even furys death seemed fake and it was revealed as such. shyt is for kids.

you only know it's fake because it proved to be fake after the fact as he laid in bed and flatlined you thought they actually had the balls to kill him like everyone else, stop it. He's only featured in 1 marvel flick since and now he's done if I am not mistaken so it was very realistic that that could've been a fitting exit

I saw it first day at the theater...like that would make a difference.

it makes a huge difference because the sound is enhanced like a mother, TDK was a harsh example of that

 

[Poetical Poltergeist]

you only know it's fake because it proved to be fake after the fact as he laid in bed and flatlined you thought they actually had the balls to kill him like everyone else, stop it. He's only featured in 1 marvel flick since and now he's done if I am not mistaken so it was very realistic that that could've been a fitting exit it makes a huge difference because the sound is enhanced like a mother, TDK was a harsh example of that

Stupid response.

 

[Roman Brady]

Its the 2nd best mcu film. Not even close to the best comic book film.

Its not even the best comic book film the year it came out.

2nd best? Then what is the best

 

[Roman Brady]

Stupid response.

Funny I felt the same about yours but could articulate why nvm

 

[Dominic Brehetto]

2nd best? Then what is the best

Iron is the better mcu film. Spider man 1&2,xmen 1&2,dofp and blade 1/2 are the better marvel films. And days of future past is the best comic book film that year. Winter soldier was a 7.5/10