Confederate Flag Debate

HellRell804

Banned
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
4,327
Reputation
2,745
Daps
22,902
Reppin
NULL
I know this is the internet where everything is black and white and there's no room for nuance, but the civil war wasn't fought to end slavery. Even Lincoln said if he could end the war without freeing a single slave he would...

With that said, on the issue of a massive powerful federal government vs. Individual states having the right to govern themselves, the South was probably right. The federal government as we know it has only grown larger and more corrupt. And the centralization of all that power has created a class of people who are above regular citizens and above the law...
 

Devilinurear

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
26,471
Reputation
5,682
Daps
86,825
Reppin
NULL
I know this is the internet where everything is black and white and there's no room for nuance, but the civil war wasn't fought to end slavery. Even Lincoln said if he could end the war without freeing a single slave he would...

With that said, on the issue of a massive powerful federal government vs. Individual states having the right to govern themselves, the South was probably right. The federal government as we know it has only grown larger and more corrupt. And the centralization of all that power has created a class of people who are above regular citizens and above the law...
States left to there own devices are just as corrupt so fukk out of here with that bullshyt.
 

HellRell804

Banned
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
4,327
Reputation
2,745
Daps
22,902
Reppin
NULL
States left to there own devices are just as corrupt so fukk out of here with that bullshyt.

Yea but the leaders of your state are actually accessible to you. You might see them out shopping or eating. Way easier to hold them accountable vs a group of legacy politicians walked in DC surrounded by secret service

Not to mention, if you don't like the way a state is run you could always move to a state whose government better aligns with your views
 

Devilinurear

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
26,471
Reputation
5,682
Daps
86,825
Reppin
NULL
Yea but the leaders of your state are actually accessible to you. You might see them out shopping or eating. Way easier to hold them accountable vs a group of legacy politicians walked in DC surrounded by secret service
How much access did people have to politicians when jim crow was around and strong.
Was it a state supreme court that decided segregation was wrong and enforced it?
 

Spatial Paradox

All Star
Supporter
Joined
May 16, 2012
Messages
2,280
Reputation
1,110
Daps
12,096
Reppin
Brooklyn
I know this is the internet where everything is black and white and there's no room for nuance, but the civil war wasn't fought to end slavery. Even Lincoln said if he could end the war without freeing a single slave he would...

With that said, on the issue of a massive powerful federal government vs. Individual states having the right to govern themselves, the South was probably right. The federal government as we know it has only grown larger and more corrupt. And the centralization of all that power has created a class of people who are above regular citizens and above the law...

The Union didn't originally go to war to end slavery, but that ended up being the goal in the end. And even acknowledging that the North didn't originally go to war to end slavery doesn't preclude the fact that slavery was the cause of the war. Every other factor I'm sure was mentioned in that video would all somehow, someway, tie back into slavery.
 

HellRell804

Banned
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
4,327
Reputation
2,745
Daps
22,902
Reppin
NULL
How much access did people have to politicians when jim crow was around and strong.
Was it a state supreme court that decided segregation was wrong and enforced it?

Jim Crow laws were local, meaning if you didn't like it you could move. And lots of black people did move up north and out west.

As far as segregation, I'm on record here saying integration was a mistake. Yea we had less than, but building things always takes time and there are always setbacks. Black people would have been better off doing for self instead of handing over their children and their future to avoid the hard work of being self sufficient
 
Top