Do you believe that civil war was as good as starwars episodes 4, 6?
"Civil War shyts on every Star Wars movie by itself except for ESB" -Ziggiy
- Thread starter Ed MOTHERFUCKING G
- Start date
Nah. I love civil war but nah. New hope?? Come on now. Even if it's even with Jedi, new hope is in another field. shyt rogue one is on the same level as civil war and may be better
so I feel 
AnonymityX1000
Veteran
It's not a fair comparison those movies have had the opportunity to age, gain their cult/nostalgia status, etc. CW came out last year.
But personally I say Ep 6 > CW > Ep 4. But really it's splitting hairs they are all great fantasy fun.
Alpha Male
Spare me your daps
Star Wars is a better film than Civil War and I'm not even taking it's contextual status into account. Nostalgia has little to do with it.
The story is better, the characters are better, the visuals and aesthetic is better, the music is better, the dialogue is better... etc.
AnonymityX1000
Veteran
Luke vs Darth is interesting, Obi Wan vs Darth . . . isn't.
AnonymityX1000
Veteran
No the visuals are not better and action wise it aged terribly. And characters/acting, I disagree as well.
Idk about the dialogue cause Lucas' pen is type questionable lol but everything else yes. Especially the action and music and just the craft behind it.
Mic-Nificent
I didn't eat nobody
There's no reason for Spider-Man to be there at all. The entire movie just stops to shoehorn him into the movie and his presence runs counter to Tony's entire motivation. He feels guilt for getting a kid killed so he endangers another kid?
I don't see how you can say with a straight face that Black Panther had no reason to be there. Wakaknda was backing the Sokovia accords, Wakandans died during the incident in Lagos, and the fukking King was assassinated when the accords were being ratified.
Ironman
#Knickstape
Nah. Nah. Nope. Black Panther was the only reason I was excited for the movie in the first place. The score alone>>>>>>>>>
I..... guess.
As a comic fan, CW and Winter Soldier will leave you
But in an era of no spoilers? Empire Strikes Back left scars on many a first watcher's soul. ROTJ, folks went back for closure like watch an abusive ex get jail time.
Then complained about fukking ewoks.
As a comic fan, CW and Winter Soldier will leave you
But in an era of no spoilers? Empire Strikes Back left scars on many a first watcher's soul. ROTJ, folks went back for closure like watch an abusive ex get jail time.
Then complained about fukking ewoks.
Mic-Nificent
I didn't eat nobody
I..... guess.
As a comic fan, CW and Winter Soldier will leave you
But in an era of no spoilers? Empire Strikes Back left scars on many a first watcher's soul. ROTJ, folks went back for closure like watch an abusive ex get jail time.
Then complained about fukking ewoks.
I swear folks entire perception of the Star Wars saga is fukking warped by nostalgia. I love the original trilogy, but not so much that I'll ignore all the flaws.
fukking Leia had an terrible British accent in one scene and then it just disappears. The entire "Luke and Leia are brother and sister" thing was CLEARLY added after the fact, because Luke was downright lusting over Leia in the first film. Star Wars is arguably the most influential franchise of all time, but people go out of their way ignore all the nonsensical shyt in those movies.
But that's the thing, though.
I don't think folks complained til like YEARS later.
I’d put it above the Star Wars prequels and The Force Awakens, but over A New Hope? Nah.
I liked the movie and all but on a pure story level, Civil War is a mess. It was trying to be a Winter Soldier sequel, a third Avengers movie, and a Black Panther origin story all at once and didn’t manage to bring those elements together in any kind of satisfactory way.
A New Hope, on the other hand, just tells a simple story with clearly-defined characters, stakes, a memorable villain, and doesn’t waste time with needless cameos and franchise-building. I mean, Black Panther was great and easily the best part of CW because he's the only character who has a complete character arc informed by what happens in the movie, but was there any reason Spider-Man had to be there other than to advertise Homecoming?
I liked the movie and all but on a pure story level, Civil War is a mess. It was trying to be a Winter Soldier sequel, a third Avengers movie, and a Black Panther origin story all at once and didn’t manage to bring those elements together in any kind of satisfactory way.
A New Hope, on the other hand, just tells a simple story with clearly-defined characters, stakes, a memorable villain, and doesn’t waste time with needless cameos and franchise-building. I mean, Black Panther was great and easily the best part of CW because he's the only character who has a complete character arc informed by what happens in the movie, but was there any reason Spider-Man had to be there other than to advertise Homecoming?
