good analysis. everyone always brings up Gamboa but at lower weight Gamboa is fast as shyt with real amateur pedigree. much faster than Floyd at WW. now at 130, Floyd was a different animal. not that pot-shot artist he became at higher weights. Floyd was offensive machine. he was much more cautious at higher weights. dont forget, Chop Chop hurt Floyd BAD at 140, worse than Gamboa did Bud. if that was Bud that rocked him, he'd been done. Bud starts slow, sort of like Floyd because he likes to figure out what the opponent has.
Spence aggressive bullying style I feel plays right in to Floyd's style. Floyd likes that shyt. I dont think he likes fighting classic boxers or slicker fighters as much as he likes guys that come forward hard.
the interesting thing about Floyd, as great as he was even up to 40 years of age is that he was much better offensively each class you go down in weight. he was really defensive at 147 and didnt throw many punches at all. He was an exciting fighter at 140, even more at 135, even more at 130.
True, you got a point with Corley. And Zab did give Floyd some trouble early too, Crawford's slickness could definitely be a problem. Zab was arguably faster than Floyd tho, Crawford definitely ain't. And he's not defensively as nice as Floyd either, which I why I think Floyd would figure him out eventually and get a clean decision. I just don't see this dude getting outboxed. And even if he does get hurt at some point, the man got a chin. Corley, Mosley, Maidana, Cotto, none of those dudes managed to put him down, Crawford gotta be something real special to pull that off and I haven't seen enough of him at 147 to know if he is or isn't.
I still lean towards Errol being the tougher fight just because I think he has the footwork and the skill to find Floyd, and he goes to the body foreal. He's not just head hunting like most of these dudes who end up hitting shoulders and arms all night. But if he can't cut the ring off on Floyd then yeah he'd definitely get pot-shotted all night.
Honestly, I really wanna see some combo of Spence Crawford and Thurman actually get in the ring before I really start saying any of them could see Floyd. If Crawford ends up dancing on Spence all night then we know Spence probably wouldn't have had enough for Floyd, but if Spence eventually ends up walking Crawford down then maybe he'd make it interesting with Floyd. And if Thurman manages to outbox either one of them or even keep it to a close decision then I highly doubt they could hang with Floyd. Once the guys at the top actually start fighting each other then we'll really see who's foreal.