Cotto was overhyped, but let's be honest, that wasn't his really his fault. He never liked being compared to Trinidad and spent his whole career trying to get out of Tito's shadow. The only reason Cotto was compared to Trinidad, is because they were both Rican, and Tito was the last successful Rican in boxing at the time. It's no different than people calling Broner the next Mayweather and Donaire the next Pacquiao.
The comparison was always fukking stupid as hell, because Cotto and Trinidad are NOTHING alike. From personality/demeanor to in-ring fighting styles. Now Felix Verdejo on the other hand, could be compared to Tito. He's got personality like Tito, and his fighting style is more like Tito's. Then again, he's also around my age, so I can see why that's the case.