I don't think it's accurate to completely chalk the rampant crime in African-American communities up to only external systematic oppression. Yes, there are many tangible ways in which it does contribute to the problem, but it is certainly not the end all be all itself. There are other poor non-white urban communities in the US that have don't have anywhere near the amount of violent crime in their communities as is present in certain segments of the African-American community, even when you adjust for the income and development environment(urban,suburban, rural etc) factors.
For instance, while contrary to the bs spewed by keyboard klansmen WS, blacks, when adjusted for income and development environment, have a lower violent crime rate than whites, BUT hispanics have a much lower violent crime rate than both using the same metric.
https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/hpnvv0812.pdf
So, yes systematic oppression does have SOMETHING, but not EVERYTHING to do with crime.
Lack of education, mental illness, personality disorders, lack of supervision & role models for children, backwards cultural values/morals/principles, piss poor/corrupt policing, and collective apathy towards the issues are just some, along with economics, that lead to the extremely high rate of crime experience in many(not most) majority African-American communities.
There are just some of the serious clear internal dysfunctions in the African-American community that don't primarily have to do with systematic oppression. All of them deserved to be addressed in their own right, as well as crime itself, along with systematic oppression. It's not a zero sum game. We can and should address the internal dysfunctions AND systematic oppression that affects our community.
Iraqi-Americans and Burmese-Americans have an even lower average household income than African-Americans yet violent crime in their communities is no where near as prevalent as it is in ours.
List of ethnic groups in the United States by household income - Wikipedia
We can't just pretend like there aren't other internal factors from within our community, particularly relating to culture, that contribute to the problem of violent crime in our community.
For instance, while contrary to the bs spewed by keyboard klansmen WS, blacks, when adjusted for income and development environment, have a lower violent crime rate than whites, BUT hispanics have a much lower violent crime rate than both using the same metric.
https://www.bjs.gov/content/pub/pdf/hpnvv0812.pdf
So, yes systematic oppression does have SOMETHING, but not EVERYTHING to do with crime.
Lack of education, mental illness, personality disorders, lack of supervision & role models for children, backwards cultural values/morals/principles, piss poor/corrupt policing, and collective apathy towards the issues are just some, along with economics, that lead to the extremely high rate of crime experience in many(not most) majority African-American communities.
There are just some of the serious clear internal dysfunctions in the African-American community that don't primarily have to do with systematic oppression. All of them deserved to be addressed in their own right, as well as crime itself, along with systematic oppression. It's not a zero sum game. We can and should address the internal dysfunctions AND systematic oppression that affects our community.
Iraqi-Americans and Burmese-Americans have an even lower average household income than African-Americans yet violent crime in their communities is no where near as prevalent as it is in ours.
List of ethnic groups in the United States by household income - Wikipedia
We can't just pretend like there aren't other internal factors from within our community, particularly relating to culture, that contribute to the problem of violent crime in our community.
Last edited: