Better Foreign Crime Show: Narcos vs Gomorrah

Better Crime Show?

  • Narcos

  • Gomorrah


Results are only viewable after voting.

Mike Nasty

Superstar
Joined
Nov 19, 2016
Messages
12,454
Reputation
2,247
Daps
60,766
Why does everyone like Narcos so much when it's a cheap, short knock off of the actual show "El Patron del Mal".
 

Sonny Bonds

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
Apr 24, 2014
Messages
4,695
Reputation
956
Daps
13,417
I'm on episode 10 of season 2:
Ciro just caught Patrizia and I'm pretty sure they gonna kill her and her brother
 

BK360NATL

Pro
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
726
Reputation
240
Daps
2,355
Reppin
NULL
Why does everyone like Narcos so much when it's a cheap, short knock off of the actual show "El Patron del Mal".

I got a lot to say on this, esp. since I've seen all 3 series.

El Patron del Mal was the Colombian version of events re: Pablo and the Medellin Cartel. It went to much deeper and darker places than Narcos ever could, based on the subject matter and the parties involved. For me, it was the superior Pablo Escobar series by far. They showed some US involvement, but most definitely, at arm's length, at best. Only thing that may turn people off would be the Spanish language and English subtitles thing. But, I ended up binge watching the 70+ episodes (approx. 60 mins each) over the course of a week.

Narcos is only built to be Americanized entertainment, with a loose interpretation of what transpired, to make Americans feel good. It's good for what it is.

Having traveled to Colombia extensively for many years now, Narcos lost me when, in the early episodes, a blond American was running around the barrio caliente in the 1980s chasing drug dealers, speaking no Spanish at all and no fear. THAT was a major exaggeration, to say the least. Then him beating up a taxi driver down in Bogota??? Dude would not have left that block alive. US intel guys, back in that time, wouldn't move anywhere in Colombia without a heavy team and local resources. They HAD to be escorted by police/private security from the airport to their hotel, and all around.

Narcos insinuated heavy US involvement in everything, which really wasn't the case. Just another attempt at rewriting history. The US provided technology for logistics, at best. Narcos had no clue on how to retell the AUC/FARC portion of events during Escobar's season, which led to even more damage being done to Colombia 20 years after Pablo died. The Castranos would've been nastier villains in that, since they dealt with both Pablo's world and the civil war's world. The Cali Cartel season was much more watered down than what really went down. Narcos appeared to have limited (or selective) source materials for the series. I can only imagine what the Mexican season will be. I'll watch it, but El Chapo is the standard for Mexican mafiosos, but even that left a ton of stuff out.

Gomorrah is in the similar gritty, non-glamorized style that El Patron del Mal was. Nothing glamorous about that life. Even Genny had to grow up out of that.
Ciro was a demon, but something got in my eye when they took out his daughter. Pietro and Imma were straight demons. Malammore was a demon. Schianel is a demon and terrorized her daughter-in-law, even though she brought it on herself too. Patrizia is now a demon. Nobody has any redeeming values anymore. O'prinicipe had the block for a minute, had the African chick, the tiger and the cars.....seemed like a good dude....they had to get him out of there.....
It's not about making anyone feel comfortable. It's a grimy world and Gomorrah pulls you into it. You don't feel that great after watching it....and wanting to see more. Hahaha.

Gomorrah for me, by far, over Narcos. 3 seasons deep with the 4th on the way in 2019.

El Patron del Mal > Gomorrah > Narcos
 
Last edited:

HollywoodP

#LongLive24 #TMC America's Team, Lakeshow, & ASU
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
12,324
Reputation
2,218
Daps
22,127
Reppin
The Valley Of The Sun 602🌵480🌵623🌵520
Narcos is coo. First two seasons were dope...I haven't really been motivated to check out season 3 yet.

Gomorrah on the other hand had me binge watching and anticipating the 3rd season for months. Season 4 with Blue Blood is gonna be...:blessed:

Gomorrah and its not even close.
 

Nero Christ

Sniper out now on all digital platforms brev
Joined
Jan 15, 2017
Messages
42,307
Reputation
13,787
Daps
147,808
Reppin
St. Lucia
I got a lot to say on this, esp. since I've seen all 3 series.

El Patron del Mal was the Colombian version of events re: Pablo and the Medellin Cartel. It went to much deeper and darker places than Narcos ever could, based on the subject matter and the parties involved. For me, it was the superior Pablo Escobar series by far. They showed some US involvement, but most definitely, at arm's length, at best. Only thing that may turn people off would be the Spanish language and English subtitles thing. But, I ended up binge watching the 70+ episodes (approx. 60 mins each) over the course of a week.

Narcos is only built to be Americanized entertainment, with a loose interpretation of what transpired, to make Americans feel good. It's good for what it is.

Having traveled to Colombia extensively for many years now, Narcos lost me when, in the early episodes, a blond American was running around the barrio caliente in the 1980s chasing drug dealers, speaking no Spanish at all and no fear. THAT was a major exaggeration, to say the least. Then him beating up a taxi driver down in Bogota??? Dude would not have left that block alive. US intel guys, back in that time, wouldn't move anywhere in Colombia without a heavy team and local resources. They HAD to be escorted by police/private security from the airport to their hotel, and all around.

Narcos insinuated heavy US involvement in everything, which really wasn't the case. Just another attempt at rewriting history. The US provided technology for logistics, at best. Narcos had no clue on how to retell the AUC/FARC portion of events during Escobar's season, which led to even more damage being done to Colombia 20 years after Pablo died. The Castranos would've been nastier villains in that, since they dealt with both Pablo's world and the civil war's world. The Cali Cartel season was much more watered down than what really went down. Narcos appeared to have limited (or selective) source materials for the series. I can only imagine what the Mexican season will be. I'll watch it, but El Chapo is the standard for Mexican mafiosos, but even that left a ton of stuff out.
Gomorrah is in the similar gritty, non-glamorized style that El Patron del Mal was. Nothing glamorous about that life. Even Genny had to grow up out of that. Ciro was a demon, but something got in my eye when they took out his daughter. Pietro and Imma were straight demons. Malammore was a demon. Schianel is a demon and terrorized her daughter-in-law, even though she brought it on herself too. Patrizia is now a demon. Nobody has any redeeming values anymore. O'prinicipe had the block for a minute, had the African chick, the tiger and the cars.....seemed like a good dude....they had to get him out of there..... It's not about making anyone feel comfortable. It's a grimy world and Gomorrah pulls you into it. You don't feel that great after watching it....and wanting to see more. Hahaha.

Gomorrah for me, by far, over Narcos. 3 seasons deep with the 4th on the way in 2019.

El Patron del Mal > Gomorrah > Narcos


breh I'd put them Gomorrah paragraphs in a spoiler so people who haven't seen the show & want to aren't spoiled
 

The axe murderer

For I am death and I ride on a pale horse
Joined
Aug 27, 2015
Messages
40,319
Reputation
6,148
Daps
138,012
I got a lot to say on this, esp. since I've seen all 3 series.

El Patron del Mal was the Colombian version of events re: Pablo and the Medellin Cartel. It went to much deeper and darker places than Narcos ever could, based on the subject matter and the parties involved. For me, it was the superior Pablo Escobar series by far. They showed some US involvement, but most definitely, at arm's length, at best. Only thing that may turn people off would be the Spanish language and English subtitles thing. But, I ended up binge watching the 70+ episodes (approx. 60 mins each) over the course of a week.

Narcos is only built to be Americanized entertainment, with a loose interpretation of what transpired, to make Americans feel good. It's good for what it is.

Having traveled to Colombia extensively for many years now, Narcos lost me when, in the early episodes, a blond American was running around the barrio caliente in the 1980s chasing drug dealers, speaking no Spanish at all and no fear. THAT was a major exaggeration, to say the least. Then him beating up a taxi driver down in Bogota??? Dude would not have left that block alive. US intel guys, back in that time, wouldn't move anywhere in Colombia without a heavy team and local resources. They HAD to be escorted by police/private security from the airport to their hotel, and all around.

Narcos insinuated heavy US involvement in everything, which really wasn't the case. Just another attempt at rewriting history. The US provided technology for logistics, at best. Narcos had no clue on how to retell the AUC/FARC portion of events during Escobar's season, which led to even more damage being done to Colombia 20 years after Pablo died. The Castranos would've been nastier villains in that, since they dealt with both Pablo's world and the civil war's world. The Cali Cartel season was much more watered down than what really went down. Narcos appeared to have limited (or selective) source materials for the series. I can only imagine what the Mexican season will be. I'll watch it, but El Chapo is the standard for Mexican mafiosos, but even that left a ton of stuff out.

Gomorrah is in the similar gritty, non-glamorized style that El Patron del Mal was. Nothing glamorous about that life. Even Genny had to grow up out of that. Ciro was a demon, but something got in my eye when they took out his daughter. Pietro and Imma were straight demons. Malammore was a demon. Schianel is a demon and terrorized her daughter-in-law, even though she brought it on herself too. Patrizia is now a demon. Nobody has any redeeming values anymore. O'prinicipe had the block for a minute, had the African chick, the tiger and the cars.....seemed like a good dude....they had to get him out of there..... It's not about making anyone feel comfortable. It's a grimy world and Gomorrah pulls you into it. You don't feel that great after watching it....and wanting to see more. Hahaha.

Gomorrah for me, by far, over Narcos. 3 seasons deep with the 4th on the way in 2019.

El Patron del Mal > Gomorrah > Narcos
You watch Suburra? I heard it was kinda like Gomorrah
 
Top